Bret Sabermetric wrote: It's always the manager's call who to put in the rotation and who in the bullpen. You're being remarkably evasive about answering my question. your question seems pretty absurd. there is not, never has been, and never will be, a manager willing to cut bait with a starter as accomplished as pedro based on a handful of starts. under the circumstances you are describing (he keeps gettng tired in the 3rd inning) i'd look to place him on the disabled list, because he's obviously suffering from something. but lets take a different set of circumstances- he's struggling period. he isn't getting tired, he isn't hurt, he's just flat out sucking, how much time does he get to straighten it out? for me, assuming the other 4 starters are pitching well and you have a guy ready to step in i'd give him about 15 starts because of his amazing track record. glavine gets about 10 starts in similiar circumstances, traschel 7-8, zambrano only a handful.