Edgy, the problem with that comparison, and I'm sure you didn't mean it to be an exact one, is that Valentin had a history (even if it wasn't recent) of production, while Newhan has never shown much of anything. Also, Franco is about as big a waste as Newhan is, they are both good for nothing but a single and we can't afford to carry 2 guys like that all year. I don't think there is such a thing as a situation that "isn't yet important enough to burn Julio Franco" when you consider that he's a singles hitter who plays only one position, a position which at least 3 other guys on the roster could handle in an emergency. I think the problem is that a bench composed of Castro/Chavez/Franco/Newhan/Easley just doesn't have much to it. you need a backup catcher, chavez has shown he is good, easley can hit lefties and plays 2 or 3 infield spots, that leaves either franco or newhan as the guy has to go if you want to have a fearsome hitter (relatively of course) on the bench. and i think we could use one.