I know we profoundly disagree on this topic, and that's OK. I love that retired numbers give us an opportunity to continue telling the stories about these people.
I probably have a few more years behind the cart than you, so it might mean something a little different to me. But Hodges wasn't just a manager. The people on that team speak of him with incredible reverence, not just as a player or manager, but as a person. Hodges is a hero in every sense of the word. He's likely one of the most pivotal people in the history of the franchise, in large part responsible for shaking off the "lovable losers" image. His sudden and tragic passing had a profound impact on the team for years. If having 14 on the wall gives me an opportunity tell people today who he was, then I'm all for it.
Stengel was probably more of a knee-jerk move. He was forced into retirement after breaking his hip late in the season and was more of a figurehead at that point anyway. He was the face of the franchise, for those early years. There might have been a element of an FY to the Yankees in there. It was just before my time.
I don't have a problem with Willie Mays. I think it's very similar, if not identical, to the Brewers retiring Hank Aaron's number. Both became legends in a city, Their franchises moved. They finished their careers in that original city with a different team. Mays is in the conversation for the greatest player ever. I was just a kid at the time, but I remember the joy at his arrival. Willie Mays is a Met and back in New York! I look at it as a tribute to his time in New York. Again, reasonable people can disagree on this.
If anyone isn't getting enough of a tribute, I think it's Joan Payson. She was a trailblazer. The first woman to buy a major American professional sports team using her own money rather than inheriting it. I don't know if there was another buyer in the wings, but the Mets exist because of her. She selected the name and everything. She -- and Stengel -- were the first people inducted into the Mets Hall of Fame.
When we look back at history we see the names and stats. But sometimes there is so much more to the story. If the Mets don't do good enough of a job telling these stories, that's on them.