Edgy MD wrote: Zvon wrote: d'Arnaud could frame my testicles in gold and it means jack shit if he can't block pitches properly or throw guys out. I've said it before. He has a stamina issue where he wears down way to soon. In individual games and over the long haul as well. Also that wrist cock thing. I wouldn't call it giving him a second chance. Come spring he gets to show if he has worked on and improved on where he lacks. If he hasn't he'll have to move aside for good, as far as being a first string catcher goes. He's pretty much already been relegated to 2nd string behind Rivera, IMO. Sure, but that was 2016, and now we are looking forward. Does the evidence really demonstrate that d'Arnaud distinctly or consistently allows passed balls or fails the throw out throw-out-able runners below the mean? Because I have my doubts that it does, especially considering he has worked with one or two pitchers who just don't keep an eye on the runners at all at all. Commenting as to Travis having a chance to prove himself in spring is me looking forward. To me, he does demonstrate that he is not the best choice we have for the position. I'm not concerned with "the mean". Just with what we have. He's been pretty weak behind the plate on things that he definitely can improve on. Simple things as far as I'm concerned. When was the last time Trav caught Thor? And who is the other pitcher? Now if d'Arnaud continued to hit the way we hoped he would hit, and consistently, I might feel different. He may come around someday but I'd rather not see him struggle through whatever he has to on the MLB level. I'd like to see him excel as a Metropolitan, but until he shows some improvements he goes behind Rene on my depth chart. Is Rivera the answer? For a full season? I'd think offensively we would suffer but behind the plate we'd be okay. I gotta say his bat, as bad as it was, surprised me this season. I think because a number of his hits were clutch hits. Ideally Trav or Kevin step up, or I think we need more from behind the plate than Rene. But if the team does certain things this off season to make for a better 2017, and Sandy goes with Rivera as our guy behind the plate, I'll accept it and root my ass off for him.