If he's on the roster, he'll be good. I have no doubt of that, based off what he did last year, what he did in 2009 both with and without the pain No doubt? Really? If you combine his partial seasons over the last 2 years, its about equivalent to 1 season of 17 hrs/75rbi/75r, which is okay for a GG-caliber CFer (though less productive than he was in his prime), but considerably less impressive for a corner OFer with greatly diminished range. When next April rolls around, he'll be a 34 year old with chronically debilitating knee problems who will be 3 years removed from his last good full season, and very possibly be our regular RFer. I'd say he's at least as likely as any of Bay, Dickey, or anyone else on the team to take an $18.5M dive into a tank of turds or win comeback-player-of-the-year (is that even an award in MLB?)