Lefty Specialist wrote: Spring training is around the corner, and they've improved, but is it enough? They don't have a fifth starter, a real centerfielder or a third baseman who can field the position adequately. There are people occupying all of those positions, but..... 3rd Base is an overated need, McNeil would give us above average defense there and Villar would be good at 2nd if we wanted to go that route. Villar is a career 95 OPS+ with speed, nothing amazing but if he upgrades the defense in two spots we could do worse. I think this is the 'real plan' if Davis doesn't hit like he did in 2019 Villar isn't really a defensive upgrade anywhere so much as he is a band-aid at several-- like, SEVERAL-- spots (and an offensive lottery ticket.. which is much more livable if he's a backup plan). The hopes you're outlining here aren't wildly unrealistic... but they are somewhat ungrounded. Davis could be serviceable, or more than serviceable... but he could also be the player the Astros cut bait on, who flashes periods like 2019 but doesn't consistently deliver them, while giving you negative value in every other way. (Personally, I believe in the bat-- he basically had an extended struggle with breaking pitches last year, but the quality of contact stayed the same... and his eye got better.) That uncertainty is the thing, though... and it's something that top-tier championship contenders these days don't have (see: Dodgers, Padres). Let's just say I'd much rather have-- as a 1-2 year option, on an ostensible contending team-- Turner than Davis... or Jurrickson Profar as a 3B-convertible IF/OF backup plan than Villar.