see, elster. i disagree. but not entirely. we should have been able to get more for benson, but i dont believe julio to be shitty. well, maybe i'm hoping that he's not shitty. i'm certainly rooting for him not to be shitty. i'm hoping that '05 was an aberration for him, and you should too. i'm having a hard time getting any good info on his 05 season to tell me anything otherwise (granted, i can't find corroborating evidence either), so all i have is hope. as far as trading a starter for a reliever, im certain that if we were to trade zambrano, who, for whatever strange reasons seems destined to start for us in 06, for a reliever, there would be a chorus of cheers. much as if pedro were traded for julio, there'd be a chorus of boos. yes, even from me. as to the question of "are we a better team with benson in the rotation and heilman in the pen, or with heilman in the rotation and julio in the pen?" i think we may be better in the latter than the former. and i think it is better for the long term prospects of the team that heilman be a starter than a middle reliever. i like heilmen in the rotation better than in the pen. i don't think trachsel would be a good option out of the pen. and for whatever reason, i think the mets are making a big mistake by not having considered zambrano for the pen. so if you asked me if i would have done the benson/julio trade, i'd probably say "yes, i would, but only if i can take back the seo trade" see, the benson trade is made bad by the seo trade, which is made bad by the benson trade. me, i would have traded benson for julio, kept seo in the rotation with heilman, and given zambrano the bump to the pen, where he'd have to prove himself worthy of anything more important than the 7th inning. i think right now, we have a weaker rotation than we started with, but not by much, and a stronger bullpen than we started with, but by a greater margin, and by one that makes the team perhaps better as a whole. wether or not we'll wish we had those discarded starters is something that remains to be seen. wether or not we'll need the relievers we gained is a given. also, when you factor in such things as money, potential upside, and anna benson, i think the benson/julio trade comes a bit closer in value, tho i agree we end up on the shorter end of the stick. but that in itself does not a terrible hateful trade make.