="AG/DC":xeb25qa0]How about Heilman beating Wagner?[/quote:xeb25qa0] That, along with Schoeneweis's margin over Wagner despite very similar stats, continues last month's discussion about closers not getting their due. Rockin' Doc Jun 04 2008 10:59 AM Due to his role as closer, Wagner generally receives fewer opportunities to score points. TheOldMole Jun 04 2008 11:00 AM How much better could Wagner have done? AG/DC Jun 04 2008 11:01 AM That should inform our voting, I think. I'm no exception there. themetfairy Jun 04 2008 11:07 AM ="Frayed Knot":o25k6kpw]="AG/DC":o25k6kpw]How about Heilman beating Wagner?[/quote:o25k6kpw] That, along with Schoeneweis's margin over Wagner despite very similar stats, continues last month's discussion about closers not getting their due.[/quote:o25k6kpw] Which again opens up the discussion of whether closers are truly more valuable to their teams than the set-up men. John Cougar Lunchbucket Jun 04 2008 11:08 AM I don't necessarily think the results show a flaw with us, just the limits of Schaefering in general. Results here are more or less a random snapshot, in that usage patterns don't coincide with the calendar month. Also, on the per-appearance basis (aka, "The Refreshment Index"), Wagner outscores all relievers. themetfairy Jun 04 2008 11:13 AM ="John Cougar Lunchbucket":3m4hznl6]I don't necessarily think the results show a flaw with us, just the limits of Schaefering in general.[/quote:3m4hznl6] True, especially since we don't award negative points when players have bad outings. seawolf17 Jun 04 2008 11:13 AM So if Aaron Heilman wins Player of the Month, he takes home all three trophies? Sweet. themetfairy Jun 04 2008 12:28 PM ="seawolf17":15md44kh]So if Aaron Heilman wins Player of the Month, he takes home all three trophies? Sweet.[/quote:15md44kh] I think that's the month that BG decides to amend Schaefer voting to award negative points seawolf17 Jun 04 2008 12:31 PM Nah, it's kinda like golf, where the lowest score wins. Rockin' Doc Jun 04 2008 03:12 PM metfairy - "True, especially since we don't award negative points when players have bad outings." It's rather tough to take back the beer once they've drank it.