I saw it this weekend...and was pleasantly surprised. I had been told that it sucked. That it was long and drawn out and badly in need of an editor. I still think it needed an editor, but it wasn't that bad. A couple of thoughts.... *The first hour where they were in NY needed the editor more than any other parts of the film. Ann's desperation, Denham's desperation...all of that could have been done a lot more succinctly. It's weird. After cramming all of LOTR into those nice, streamlined movies, it's almost like Jackson decided (starting with the last 45 minutes of Return of the King) "Oh fuck it, I'm going to be indulgent." I mean really, how many "You can't do this Mr. Denham, you don't have papers" scenes did we need? *The second hour of the film, as Norrin says, was the best part of the movie...and I thought it was fantastic. From the boat ride, the terrifying natives, the no-nonsense captain, the introduction of Kong, I thought it was great. And yes, it did go a little over the top with the brontosaurus stampede, leading to the cliff scene, leading to the T-Rex scene, followed by the bug scene, but even if it wandered into ridiculousness for a while, it was still fun. Although at one point, I couldn't help but wonder why 3 T-Rexes would fight so hard for Naomi Watts considering she is like a Tic Tac to them. Especially if they have to split her amongst the three of them? Aren't there a bunch of freshly killed/lame brontosauruses lying around? These are the worst predators ever. *There were lots of interesting characters, though most of them were not developed and just kind of leave you wondering. The relationship between the black sea dude and the kid...Denham's assistant...the sea captain...how the actor buy was a weenie, then brave, then a weenie again. There was potential there in all these characters but Jackson just chose to touch upon all of them rather than develop any of them. Also, I thought the acting went back and forth from stylized to realistic to stylized again. *Adrien Brody was much better than I thought he would be. I'm still not convinced he could have navigated his way around the island by himself, but he was likeable and otherwise believable. You can't help but feel bad for him when he shows up to rescue Ann and Ann gives him this look like "Well, this is kind of awkward, but I'm seeing someone else." *The last part back in New York was pretty much a disappointment. Like Norrin, I thought it got a bit silly when all of the mayhem stopped while Kong and Ann went frolicing in the park. For what it's worth, Naomi Watts did a good job with this scene...and I thought that was the only thing that kept me from actually groaning or laughing. Adrien Brody's character's involvement in this last part is weird too. I'm not sure what he's trying to accomplish, or why he's even there...it's just confusing. *The climax on the Empire State Building was nothing like I thought it would be. It wasn't exciting at all, just kind of sad. And maybe Jackson knew he couldn't top the thrill ride he gave us on the island so he took it in a different direction. Anyway, it was just a sad end to a roller coaster of a movie. Six Bananas.