Nymr83 wrote: Benitez had a "rep" as a guy who choked in clutch time as an Oriole, I'm not an Orioles fan so i couldn't list his "accomplishments" in that department but I know he was on the mound when that kid stole the ball over the wall against the yankees in the playoffs. When I mean rep, I mean as a fireballer 1-2-3 in 9 pitches type. Sure that could also be 6 pitches as well, go 0-2, bomb, go 1-2 on the next guy, BOMB...drive home safely Basically the guy you want on the mound, failures or not. Along with Mariano Rivera, who are the two greatest closers in the game's history? Goose Gossage and Dennis Eckersley, and they both gave up essentially World Series clinching HRs (to the same guy ironically enough) Both are of the PUNCH-OUT Game Over variety. There is a reason the ENTIRE Met fan community (not just online) was clamoring for him to be the closer instead of Franco back in April of 1999, and not just because of the Anti-Franco sentiments. And this is with his Baltimore failures allready established (The Maier game, also served up the ALCS winning HR to Tony Fernandez in 1997! The record for Benitez with the O's in the postseasons of 96-97 is not pretty at all, but Met fans still wanted HIM over Franco, despite Franco having senority over him, and still technically "unknown" in a true Autum Baseball environment, unlike Armando. Thats what I mean by rep.