="Valadius"] There are no true numerical indicators of greatness for a closer - not yet, anyway. I suspect that there will someday be a 500-save club that would be that milestone, but as of now it only has one member - Trevor Hoffman. But the 400 save club was just as exclusive. Should Lee Smith (who got there first) and John Franco be inducted? Plus there are actually more 300 game winners (Glavine is the 23rd) right now than 300 save closers. (an even 20) Yes I know 23 over the entire history of MLB, as opposed to 20 really since the save rule went to effect in 1969 (interestingly enough, Rollie Fingers played in 1968, the only member of the club to do so, but never recorded what would be considered a "save" ) ]How are we going to evaluate closers in the future? And how should we evaluate the closers of the past? Where is the dividing line between the modern era of closers and the past, and how should we consider closers from each? I personally think the modern era of the closer began in the early 1990's. How should we judge the closers of the 70's and 80's? Trevor Hoffman is likely going to be the first modern closer inducted into the Hall of Fame. Nope, using your criteria that is right in HOFer Dennis Eckersley's prime. -MVP & CY year in 1992 -Switches to full time closer in 1987, yeah not the 1990s, but close enough. -Modern bullpens are greatly inspired by LaRussa's A's pens with Honeycutt, Nelson and a cast of thousands filling in the bridge to Eck in the 9th. Oh sure the setup guy had existed before, but LaRussa really got the ball rolling in terms of how bullpens are set up and used today. For better or worse depending your point of view. ]Who else seems likely to join him? Rivera and Wagner stand out in my mind. But who else can we include with them? And who should we consider from the past who have been neglected? Rivera yes, Wagner? Never really thought of it that way. Tell you the truth I'm lukewarm on Hoffman for the same reasons Lee Smith and Jeff Reardon (both of whom enjoyed time being the All Time Saves leader) aren't getting in. Nothing that says "You are watching a legend" the way you do with Rivera. Like you did with Eck, Rollie Fingers, ect. Rich Gossage pretty much is the last of the pre-90s closers IMO who is not in the HOF but should be.