soupcan wrote: And there's my point. So they guy who earned the right to start the game shouldn't get to? I think that the only circumstance in which they should bat, and it happens pretty infrequently. Edit, because I wanted to know really, how often does this happen...and the answer is 8 times in the last 10 NL all-star games. Pitchers Batting in an All-Star Game -- last 10 in NL Parks: 2004 - Mulder bats for AL after AL bats around in top of 1st 2002 - Padilla (N) and Garcia (A) bat in the 11th inning game as last pitchers left 1998 - David Wells (A) bats in the bottom of the 2nd. As the starter, he had only pitched 1 inning, and went out to pitch a 2nd inning. 1992 - Charles Nagy (A) hits for himself leading off the top of the 8th with the AL up 10-1. He was removed the next inning for a new pitcher, so this one is strange. (Nagy did single and score, but still, this one was strange). Same game: Norm Charlton (N) strikes out with 2 men on to end the game. Strange. 1986 - Clemens bats once (starters were going 3 innings). Teddy Higuera (A), who also went 3 innings, bats once.