Frayed Knot wrote: Ceetar wrote: It's going to be inevitable. Runner on second 1 out, bottom nine, tie game. fly ball to center field that's called an out. runner retreats from near third back to second. replay indicates it was a fair ball. You could give the guy one base, but chances are the game should've been over. But then, it's one of those things to argue about. I assume you meant to say trapped where you wrote fair, but, yeah, that situation would result in there being at least as many arguments after the play is corrected as there might have been before the wrong call was righted and that'll be true no matter how it's corrected. Personally I'd rather argue about the call itself than about how and if the chessmen were artificially moved around after the fact. I'm not really worried about this situation, because although the run doesnt score, the outcome post-replay is still better than pre-replay (1st and 3rd with 1 out instead of runner on 2nd [3rd if he tagged] and 2 out.) If thats the rule post-replay (everyone gets one base) then its still strictly better than the botched call every time even if its not as good as the right call getting made in the first place. Its the opposite situation that concerns me. the ball is initially called trapped, so the runner scores... on replay they call it back and say it was a catch... then what? if you leave the runner at 2nd you are precluding the possibility that he would have been thrown out either retreating to 2nd or advancing to 3rd and the possibility that he would have safely advanced to 3rd anyway.