I'm doing some pre-Opening Day reconciliation on the UMDB, comparing the play-by-play data (for the scorecards) to the box score data to the year-by-year line items. And this popped up. In 1996, Carl Everett had 16 runs batted in. That appears to be the official number. However, if you look at the game logs for that year, he only has 15 runs batted in. The UMDB box score has him driving in a run on August 20, 1996. But the box scores on Retrosheet and Baseball Reference don't have that RBI. I originally got the data from Retrosheet, so I can only assume that they went back and revised their box score at some point, but to me it appears that they did so incorrectly. Here's what happened: METS 8TH: Ochoa walked; Alfonzo out on a sacrifice bunt (pitcher to second) [Ochoa to second]; TOMBERLIN BATTED FOR ORDONEZ; MCCARTY REPLACED FERNANDEZ (PLAYING 1B); CREEK REPLACED WILSON (PITCHING); C. JONES BATTED FOR TOMBERLIN; C. Jones was walked intentionally; EVERETT BATTED FOR B. JONES; Everett singled to left [Ochoa scored (error by Mueller), C. Jones to second]; Bill Mueller called for obstruction by 3B umpire Gary Darling; Alex Ochoa allowed to score which negated the putout at HP; Johnson singled to first [C. Jones scored (error by McCarty), Everett to third, Johnson to second]; BAUTISTA REPLACED CREEK (PITCHING); Espinoza reached on a fielder's choice [Everett scored, Johnson to third]; Jones beat the throw home on the fielder's choice; Gilkey out on a sacrifice fly to left [Johnson scored (unearned)]; Hundley walked [Espinoza to second]; Baerga popped to shortstop; 4 R (3 ER), 2 H, 2 E, 2 LOB. Mets 7, Giants 3. Baseball Reference wrote: Single to LF (Ground Ball thru SS-3B Hole); Ochoa Scores/Adv on E5; Jones to 2B It sounds like Ochoa was thrown out at home, but then the umpire called interference on the third baseman Mueller, which allowed the run to score. Do fielders get charged with an error when there's an interference call? I would think that if the judgment was that Ochoa would have been safe at home if not for the interference, then Everett should get credit for the RBI. And apparently he did, in the season totals, but not in the box score. It seems that no matter what I do, there will always be a discrepancy, but my inclination is to credit Everett with the RBI in this game. Where's Hal the Referee when you need him? The forum's been slow lately, so I figured I'd toss this out there for us to chew on. What do you think?