Edgy MD wrote: 1. While a better is welcome to come to the plate wearing any reinforced armor that they might choose, if the batter gets hit on any armored part of the body, apart from the neck or head, they are not ruled as hit by the pitch, they do not get a base, and the pitch counts as a ball or strike as called by the umpire. The play is called dead, and runners are returned to their bases. I think there should be an exception to this. If the ball is coming right at the hitter and he makes a clear effort to get out of the way and it happens to hit him on a padded area, it should count as a HBP. Your rule should apply in the (many) cases we see where the batter stands still and lets the ball hit him. Edgy MD wrote: 2. A ball that nicks the batter on the body or uniform but is caught on the fly by the catcher is not ruled as a hit batter, the batter does not get a base, and the pitch counts as called by the umpire. The play is live, and runners may attempt to advance. Much as a foul tip into the catcher's mitt is counted in all ways as a swing and a miss. "Nicks" is kind of subjective. I can see this making sense if the path of the ball isn't affected by the impact with the batter, but if a batter is plunked squarely in the ribs and the catcher catches the rebound, I think it should be a HBP. Edgy MD wrote: 1. A batter who is judged to have been officially hit by a pitch with ball four shall be awarded two bases, with runners advancing as forced. So it's a BB and a HBP? Interesting. Edgy MD wrote: 2. A batter who is judged to have been officially hit by a pitch in the head or neck shall be awarded two bases, with runners advancing as forced. I kinda like this. Edgy MD wrote: 3. When a batter is officially judged to have been hit by a pitch in the head or neck, the pitcher shall be removed from the game, regardless of any apparent intent or lack thereof. I don't think I like this.