="Bret Sabermetric"]All you'll have to do, as I said, is read between the lines when Mets pitchers discuss Lo Duca's skills as a catcher this season, and if you're willing to see, you'll see what they thought of Piazza's defense. I don't expect you'll be convinced but I'll take comfort from it. It's amazing that you still think Piazza was a good catcher. If he was even an average catcher, there would have been no reason at all for the Mets not to have signed him again this year, and I would have endorsed the move, but he isn't, and they didn't, so I didn;t have to. But your opinion identifies you as stubbornly deluded, and I'll preserve it as Exhibit A if anyone tries to claim that I;'ve overstated the degree of denial around here. Ah what the hell - I'll jump in. How can you be so sure that that when the pitchers are talking about LoDuca that there are in fact things to read inbetween those lines? Can't they just like him without disliking Piazza or are these ideas not mutually exclusive of one another? Now maybe you are right, maybe they never wanted to criticize Piazza because, well, he was Piazza and maybe they think that LoDuca is just a much, much, much, much, much better catcher in every single way. But you don't know that. You can opine and that's fine (I'm a poet and I know it), but we all know what happens when we assume don't we? And why is it wrong to simply believe that the Mets didn't want to invest another year and $$$ in an aging catcher who seemed as if he was starting to break down physically? Perhaps they weighed their options and thought 'Yes Piazza is fine defensively and calls a satisfactory game but he is getting older and is getting hurt more. He's not as consistent a hitter and can't throw anybody out. His contract is up why don't we just let him go and start fresh?' Why is this so unbelievable? I understand your point but you are pounding it home as if its the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth and all you have is your belief that he couldn't stop a 15 mph tumbleweed rolling lazily towards him coupled with your inbetween the lines theory. Give me something more concrete and maybe I'll come over to the dark side but until you've got Tom Glavine on a tape recorder telling me that Mikey P. had hands like a spaghetti strainer I'm not buying what your selling . ="Bret Sabermetric"] Let's try some elementary logic: Is Lo Duca an improvement defensively over Piazza? Yes. ="Bret Sabermetric"] Is he a big improvement? He's an improvement. ="Bret Sabermetric"]Does Lo Duca have a prayer of winning a Gold Glove this season? A guy has to win a gold glove to be considered 'above average'? ="Bret Sabermetric"]Final Question: does this make Piazza anywhere near average? I've never heard anyone, anywhere, besides you, deride Piazza's defensive ability so much. We know the guy can't throw but after years of watching him I think I would've noticed an overabundance of passed balls and a tendency to get out of the way of runners barreling down on him. I didn't. Take away his noodle arm and yeah, I think Piazza is an average defensive catcher.