You've got to platoon, and you've got to make that your plan. Don't just stick in some random righthander from your farm system once in a while; go out and get somebody who can hit a little and play the outfield as well as first base. I'd love it if Duda started hitting lefties better, but he's going to be 29 next year, and his career OPS against them is .610 (and he's getting worse, as Edgy points out). It's just not something you want to bank on. Duda against the righties and just an average major league hitter against the lefties adds up to an All Star. The problem is that with all the spots being taken up by relief pitchers, platooning has become much more difficult. In 1969, Hodges used a lefty-righty platoon at least part of the time everywhere but center and left. In 1986, Davey had everyday starters only at catcher, first, and right. This year, Terry really didn't platoon at all, except a bit in left field. Someone would start every day until he got hurt or was so awful that someone else had to take his place. But given the roster he had, I don't know how much more he could have done.