Taking the 'same player' label a bit too literally perhaps? ... especially considering that they're both LH-hitting mostly corner OFs with power, low-BAs, and high K-rates. 2013 - 2016 stats: BA: CG - .240, JB = .240 OBA: CG = .339 OBA; JB = .305 -- So, yeah, Grandy walks significantly more although maybe that's partly due to his leadoff role w/NYM XBHs/IsoP: CG = 193 / .193 IsoP; JB = 245 / .210 -- Bruce had about 300 more ABs (due to Grandy missing a chunk of 2013) but his power rate is higher too Grandy runs better, Bruce throws MUCH better, and I'd call the gloves a wash unless they're planning on using Grandy in CF I'm not going to argue against those who prefer Granderson, I just don't the gap is that huge and I think we may be a bit jaded by JB's bad first impression as if that's all he's ever been/ever will be. Tack onto the equation about whether the 36 y/o or the 30 y/o is more likely to see a decline and it melts away even more. I'm just saying that they're so much like the same player that it makes sense not to keep both. I don't care which they deal, but it makes sense to dangle both to see who bites. And, like I said, if Granderson truly is the better player than he'd likely get the better player back in a trade too.