batmagadanleadoff wrote: ... wasn't Benitez always one of baseball's best relievers during his years as a Met? Maybe I'm misremembering, but there were surely better relief pitchers around, but not too many. Compare AB to his contemporary closers in IP, Saves, Save Pct, ERA, BAA, WHiP, K/9, etc. and "one of the better ones" is a very accurate assessment. His detractors all then fell back to the "worst possible moment" argument but; 1) for late inning guys there rarely is a good time to have a bad game 2) a realistic reading of his blown games show his failures to be widely distributed among the opponent and time of year and that (contrary to popular belief) the only discernable pattern was that there was no discernable pattern.