I've always thought, and still think, that Thole could be the backup catcher on a good team. We've seen enough of him to know what to expect. Murphy is still a bit of a puzzle. His .299/.342/.423 line this season is almost identical to his career line (.295/.344/.437). He's a known commodity with the bat, and those numbers would be rock solid if his glove at second was at least average. He's lugging a -8 in runs saved from the Fielding Bible at second, but on the bright side it's not really a worse number than what it was in May. I don't think the Mets necessarily need to improve on him; I certainly wouldn't move him for less than a starting player, and the team has bigger issues. Like the outfield, for example... Bay has been horrible this year, and while injuries have factored in, he still hasn't given the Mets more than mediocrity for their $65 million. Torres' one good year with the bat is getting further and further away. His glove keeps him from being awful, but he's hardly inspiring and I wouldn't give him a raise to come back. Duda, quite frankly, needs a .900 OPS to make his outfield defense tolerable, and that ain't happening. He's dealable to a team looking for a first baseman or DH, but he won't boost his value playing out the string in Buffalo. Nieuwenhuis hit as well as a guy with a very high K rate in the minors and little AAA experience could be expected to hit. He has talent, but it's raw. I think he'll improve next season, but how much is an open question. I think the glass is half full with the pitching. A rotation of RA, Johan, Harvey, Niese, and Gee is actually pretty decent, especially with Wheeler getting closer to a call-up. Familia and Mejia might be in a position to help out in either the rotation or the pen -- but they should decide before training camp whether they want Mejia to pitch as a starter or reliever and then stick with it. The best thing you can say about the pen is that it can't get any worse. I'd bet on Ramirez bouncing back, but that second year they gave to Francisco is going to hurt. Parnell is what his numbers say he is, which is really not bad but nod good enough to be the closer. Alderson needs to find one or two diamonds in the rough to make the pen competitive, but that's not impossible. And there's always the question of whether or not the Mets are willing to spend. It's possible that the team will use whatever money it has lying around this offseason to extend Wright and Dickey, and that they may have to wait for Bay and Santana to come off the books to get aggressive again on the spending. But we'll see.