Edgy DC wrote: I have no problem with that vote. Does holding batters --- disproportionately good ones --- to a .200 / .286 / .288 // .574 lline matter? Now that you put it that way (I hadn't seen those splits), I guess a reporter who sees him play every day may consider him to be very valuable to his team. So a tenth place vote may be valid in the voter's mind. EDIT: And, to support your point, look what I found elsewhere: RELIEF PITCHERS W/LESS THAN 10 SAVES WHO HAVE RECEIVED MVP VOTES 2005 - Scott Eyre (1 pt.). Highlights: 2-2, 0 sv, 2.63 era. 1.08 whip. Led league with: 86 appearances. (MVP#T30/CY#--) 2001 - Steve Kline (1 pt.). Highlights: 3-3, 9 sv, 1.80 era. 1.09 whip. Led league with: 89 appearances. (MVP#24/CY#--) 1997 - Arthur Rhodes (5 pts.). Highlights: 10-3, 1 sv, 3.02 era. 1.06 whip. (MVP#T20/CY#--) 1996 - Mariano Rivera (27 pts.). Highlights: 8-3, 5 sv, 2.09 era. 0.99 whip, 10.9 k/9. (MVP#12/CY#3) 1977 - Tug McGraw (2 pts.). Highlights: 7-3, 9 sv, 2.62 era. 1.09 whip. (MVP#24/CY#--) 1975 - Paul Lindblad (7 pts.). Highlights: 9-1, 7 sv, 2.72 era. 1.21 whip. (MVP#T18/CY#--) 1974 - Al Hrabosky (4 pts.). Highlights: 8-1, 9 sv, 2.95 era. 1.23 whip. (MVP#T16/CY#5) 1966 - Jack Sanford (4 pts.). Highlights: 13-7, 5 sv, 3.83 era (league: 3.37). 1.25 whip. (MVP#T21/CY#--) 1962 - Ed Roebuck (2 pts.). Highlights: 10-2, 9 sv, 3.09 era. 1.31 whip. (MVP#T26/CY#--) 1960 - Larry Sherry (2 pts.). Highlights: 14-10, 7 sv, 3.79 era. 1.45 whip. (MVP#T20/CY#--) 1955 - Don Mossi (1 pt.). Highlights: 4-3, 9 sv, 2.42 era. 1.22 whip. 1954 - Hoyt Wilhelm (17 pts.). Highlights: 12-4, 7 sv, 2.10 era. 1.16 whip. Led league with: .750 winning pct. 1952 - Eddie Yuhas (5 pts.). Highlights: 12-2, 6 sv, 2.72 era. 1.38 whip. His career consisted of one other inning. Led league with: .857 winning pct. 1949 - Ted Wilks (8 pts.). Highlights: 10-3, 9 sv, 3.73 era. 1.21 whip. Led league with: 9 saves. 1946 - Earl Caldwell (18 pts.). Highlights: 13-4, 8 sv, 2.08 era. 0.98 whip. Finished 2nd in saves. 1943 - Johnny Murphy (1 pt.). Highlights: 12-4, 8 sv, 2.41 era. 1.09 whip. 1940 - Joe Beggs (19 pts.). Highlights: 12-3, 7 sv, 2.00 era. 1.16 whip. Led league with: 7 saves. 1938 - Mace Brown (62 pts.). Highlights: 15-9, 5 sv, 3.80 (league: 3.78 ). 1.50 whip. Led league with: 51 appearances. 1938 - Charlie Root (3 pts.). Highlights: 8-7, 8 sv, 2.86 era. 1.20 whip. Finished 2nd in both ERA title and saves. 1933 - Dolf Luque (1 pt.). Highlights: 8-2, 4 sv, 2.69 era. 1.17 whip. Also, left off the list were other pitchers who received votes while serving as swing-men or changing roles mid-season. Generally, if it looked like a big win total as a starter helped him, I discounted him as a reliever. Later