Edgy MD wrote: If pitchers who never hit are eligible and are enshrined, why not hitters who never fielded (though Martinez actually played over 500 games on defense)? A pitcher's ability to hit is not part of the job description of "pitcher". Martinez isn't a pitcher, and he is not being voted on as a pitcher. But to me, "Player" involves the classic 5 tools; hit, hit with power, field, run, throw. And IMO to be a member of the Baseball Hall of Fame, a player must do those things well enough to be worthy of the Hall, even if they don't do one of them (like run) particularly well. But he must DO them. When the rule was first announced, I thought it might have an effect on career statistics by keeping players around at the end of their careers who would otherwise have retired. I was right. Look at the numbers Paul Milotor put up after his final year as a player (at age 34). Those extra stats put him into HOF consideration by a wide margin. In the case of Martinez, those 500 games as a position player don't cut it for me. Later