You make some good points but there are several that I will take umbrage with: Edgy DC wrote: Reyes was never that good before. Reyes WAR: 2006: 5.9 2007: 5.4 2008: 5.3 2011: 5.8 Reyes is a player who derives a large percentage of his value from his legs, yet he has frequently hurt his legs. Games Played: 2005: 161 2006: 153 2007: 160 2008: 159 2010: 133 2011: 126 Reyes, while seemingly like a sweetheart, has demonstrated a penchant for self-centeredness and disengagement when he's unhappy. There's no objective measure for this but if we're discussing the implications of giving him a big pile of cash, it seems unlikely that said big pile of cash is going to make him unhappy. While Reyes was hurt, his potential replacement performed very well. I'll give you "well" without the "very" modifier. 1.6 WAR in 2011 over 376 PAs. David Wright has pants made of sugar. Jose Reyes was the most exciting player the franchise has had in 20 years, if not more. A declining shortstop is a more fearsome thing than a declining thirdbaseman, in general. Assuming you leave him at shortstop and don't move him to another position. Reyes was never such a good player and it was easy to see his excellence last year as a particularly good year by a good player See WAR table above.