I don't get the 8/9 thing either. It's just the illusion of a difference. The batting order isn't really a list, it's a cycle. It has to start somewhere, (in the first inning, of course) but then it's a rotation. This: Granderson Wright Duda Cuddyer Murphy d'Arnaud Flores Pitcher Lagares Is only nominally different from this: Lagares Granderson Wright Duda Cuddyer Murphy d'Arnaud Flores Pitcher It may make the manager look like he's thinking outside the box, but it really means next to nothing, except to Juan Lagares, who, as noted, will be getting significantly fewer plate appearances.