Frayed Knot Old-Timey Member Posted November 6, 2017 Posted November 6, 2017 As referenced in the ‘Coaches’ thread, new bench coach Gary DiSarcina is one of 170 players in ML history who played a career of 10 or more seasons exclusively with one ML club, a list which begins with Hall of Famer Bid McPhee (Reds: 1882-1899) and ends with this year’s retirement of Matt Cain (Giants: 2005-2017). DiSarcina played 12 ML seasons, all of them with the (Anaheim/California/Los Angeles/SoCal) Angels.But can you name the remaining 12 players fitting this category who started their careers since 1990?All players must be retired so one-teamers like Ryan Zimmerman don't count, nor does David Wright even if you spend your spare time cooking up schemes where he'll retire before opening day 2018.The players are sorted from earliest debut to most recent so those and the length of career numbers are hints; not sure if they're good hints, but they're something.PLAYERTEAMYEARSDEBUT154/8/91167/7/91148/21/92199/11/93114/26/95124/29/95195/23/95205/29/95179/24/95178/2/97159/24/97105/26/01— MATT CAIN ---- GIANTS —138/29/05
seawolf17 Old-Timey Member Posted November 6, 2017 Posted November 6, 2017 Cap'n Intangibles is in there somewhere. Probably the 5/29/95 one + twenty years.
Frayed Knot Old-Timey Member Posted November 6, 2017 Author Posted November 6, 2017 PLAYERTEAMYEARSDEBUT154/8/91167/7/91148/21/92199/11/93114/26/95124/29/95195/23/95DEREK JETERYANX205/29/95179/24/95178/2/97159/24/97105/26/01— MATT CAIN ---- GIANTS —138/29/05Seawolf +5
Gwreck Old-Timey Member Posted November 6, 2017 Posted November 6, 2017 Jeff Bagwell should be one of the 1991 debuts.
Guest d'Kong76 Guests Posted November 6, 2017 Posted November 6, 2017 (edited) Chipper must fit in there somewhere.OE: too slow Edited November 6, 2017 by Guest
HahnSolo Old-Timey Member Posted November 6, 2017 Posted November 6, 2017 (edited) Larry Jones the 19 year guy that debuted September 1993.Oe: Zoinks! Edited November 6, 2017 by Guest
Guest d'Kong76 Guests Posted November 6, 2017 Posted November 6, 2017 Big eared catcher on the Yanks named Jorge too, I imagine.
Frayed Knot Old-Timey Member Posted November 6, 2017 Author Posted November 6, 2017 (edited) PLAYERTEAMYEARSDEBUTJEFF BAGWELLASTROS154/8/91167/7/91148/21/92CHIPPER JONESBRAVES199/11/93114/26/95124/29/95195/23/95DEREK JETERYANX205/29/95JORGE POSADAYANX179/24/95178/2/97159/24/97105/26/01— MATT CAIN ---- GIANTS —138/29/05Seawolf +5GWreck +541Forever +3 (for the right guy)Hahn Solo +2 (for the right slot)d'KONG +3 Edited November 6, 2017 by Guest
HahnSolo Old-Timey Member Posted November 6, 2017 Posted November 6, 2017 Todd Helton is one.I'll guess the 5/23/95, even though I think his full rookie season was '97?
Frayed Knot Old-Timey Member Posted November 6, 2017 Author Posted November 6, 2017 PLAYERTEAMYEARSDEBUTJEFF BAGWELLASTROS154/8/91BERNIE WILLIAMSYANX167/7/91148/21/92CHIPPER JONESBRAVES199/11/93114/26/95124/29/95MARIANO RIVERAYANX195/23/95DEREK JETERYANX205/29/95JORGE POSADAYANX179/24/95TODD HELTONROCKIES178/2/97159/24/97105/26/01— MATT CAIN ---- GIANTS —138/29/05Seawolf +5GWreck +5 +3 (Williams)41Forever +3 (for the right guy)Hahn Solo +2 (for the right slot) +3 (Helton) +3 (Rivera)d'KONG +3... and NOW it starts to get tougher!!Additional hint: All five remaining are AL'ers
HahnSolo Old-Timey Member Posted November 6, 2017 Posted November 6, 2017 I was typing Garret Anderson but now I think he may have finished off with a year in the NL (Cubs?).Anyhow, I'll still go with Anderson.
Frayed Knot Old-Timey Member Posted November 6, 2017 Author Posted November 6, 2017 -1 point for Hahn on G. Anderson
Centerfield Old-Timey Member Posted November 6, 2017 Posted November 6, 2017 (edited) BiggioOn edit. Al’ers. Oops. Rmpl Edited November 6, 2017 by Guest
HahnSolo Old-Timey Member Posted November 6, 2017 Posted November 6, 2017 Brad Radke? Unless he mopped up with someone late in his career.
Frayed Knot Old-Timey Member Posted November 6, 2017 Author Posted November 6, 2017 Biggio also debuted in 1988 so missed the cutoff for this quiz.But Hahn hits on Brad RadkePLAYERTEAMYEARSDEBUTJEFF BAGWELLASTROS154/8/91BERNIE WILLIAMSYANX167/7/91148/21/92CHIPPER JONESBRAVES199/11/93114/26/95BRAD RADKETWINS124/29/95MARIANO RIVERAYANX195/23/95DEREK JETERYANX205/29/95JORGE POSADAYANX179/24/95TODD HELTONROCKIES178/2/97159/24/97105/26/01— MATT CAIN ---- GIANTS —138/29/05Seawolf +5GWreck +5 +3 (Williams)41Forever +3 (for the right guy - Chipper)Hahn Solo +2 (for the right slot - Chipper) +3 (Helton) +3 (Rivera) - 1 (Anderson) +3 (Radke)CF -1d'KONG +3
ashie62 Old-Timey Member Posted November 6, 2017 Posted November 6, 2017 Eric Karros and Royce Clayton
Frayed Knot Old-Timey Member Posted November 6, 2017 Author Posted November 6, 2017 No on Karros although that one was close (debuted in '91 but finished up with brief runs at CHC & OAK) but a very big no on Clayton who played for 11 different clubs over 17 seasons (-2)
Guest 41Forever Guests Posted November 6, 2017 Posted November 6, 2017 I was thinking Joe Mauer, but it looks like he's still playing!
Frayed Knot Old-Timey Member Posted November 6, 2017 Author Posted November 6, 2017 Very much so (hit .304 this year) although next season is the final year in the longterm deal he signed with the Twins to keep the local boy away from Free agency back in 2010 or '11Not sure what the market will be for him after that, he turns 35 next April, hasn't been behind the plate since 2013, and doesn't really have 1B power.
Frayed Knot Old-Timey Member Posted November 6, 2017 Author Posted November 6, 2017 Here's the thing about Ryan Howard: he's correct, but wasn't on the list that I cribbed this quiz from.Maybe they thought he's not really retired (he's still claiming he wants to play even after being cut by Atlanta last year when they refused to call him up even after Freeman went down with a broken hand)But, seeing as how he hasn't suited up in an ML uni since 2016, I'm counting it and will have to add him to the grid.So 'Yes', but still four answers out there.PLAYERTEAMYEARSDEBUTJEFF BAGWELLASTROS154/8/91BERNIE WILLIAMSYANX167/7/91148/21/92CHIPPER JONESBRAVES199/11/93114/26/95BRAD RADKETWINS124/29/95MARIANO RIVERAYANX195/23/95DEREK JETERYANX205/29/95JORGE POSADAYANX179/24/95TODD HELTONROCKIES178/2/97159/24/97105/26/01RYAN HOWARDPHILLIES139/1/04— MATT CAIN ---- GIANTS —138/29/05Edgy +5
Frayed Knot Old-Timey Member Posted November 6, 2017 Author Posted November 6, 2017 BOOM like that.PLAYERTEAMYEARSDEBUTJEFF BAGWELLASTROS154/8/91BERNIE WILLIAMSYANX167/7/91148/21/92CHIPPER JONESBRAVES199/11/93BOBBY HIGGINSONTIGERS114/26/95BRAD RADKETWINS124/29/95MARIANO RIVERAYANX195/23/95DEREK JETERYANX205/29/95JORGE POSADAYANX179/24/95TODD HELTONROCKIES178/2/97159/24/97105/26/01RYAN HOWARDPHILLIES139/1/04— MATT CAIN ---- GIANTS —138/29/05Edgy +5 (Ryan Howard) +3 (Higginson)Two of the remaining three are from the same team (but not from a team already on the board).
Frayed Knot Old-Timey Member Posted November 6, 2017 Author Posted November 6, 2017 Edgar fits the one team requirement but, alas, he made his ML debut way back in 1987.He, along with Tom Pagnozzi ('88), Chris Hoiles ('89), the previously guessed Craig Biggio ('88), and the inspiration for this quiz Gary DiSarcina ('89), were the final players debuting in the '80s who were one-team/ten-year gents.
Centerfield Old-Timey Member Posted November 6, 2017 Posted November 6, 2017 seawolf17 wrote:Edgar Martinez?Yeah, everyone I think of is too old. Pretty sure Cal Ripken debuted before '91.
Frayed Knot Old-Timey Member Posted November 6, 2017 Author Posted November 6, 2017 The final blank on the board I don't think anyone is getting because he manages to hit all the marks for remaining obscure despite a decade long career: - he just made it to the minimum 10 years- a pitcher but never started a single game- AL West so we rarely if ever saw him since his appearances usually came about 1AM our time (y'know, when Omar likes to fire managers)But one of the others was from the same team ('92 to '06 - so a partial overlap of careers), was a good if not great player (never an All-Star yet two Top-10 MVPs) and should be a guy you associate with one club.The other is an AL East guy often in the thick of the MFY rivalry.
Zach Thornton Syracuse Mets - AAA LHP On Sunday, the southpaw tossed five shutout innings as the bulk pitcher. He gave up 2 hits, walked 2 and had 5 strikeouts. Explore Zach Thornton News >
Recommended Posts