The Dwight Gooden Award

[ashie62]

1. Davis
2. Niese
3. Thole
4 Takahashi
5. Gee

[Vic Sage]

G-Fafif wrote: 1. Davis 2. Niese 3. Takahashi 4. Tejada 5. Thole

Tejada? really? not only instead of Carter, but ahead of Thole?
'splain, please. oh, wait. you think defense matters. ok.

[Theoldmole]

Davis
Takahashi
Thole
Niese
Carter

[duan]

I don't get the gr� for Ike Davis' season. He did OK, but as a 1b man he was distinctly average - and average is fine - but Tak was a VERY good reliever and OK starter and Niese was good starter, both of those beat being an OK 1b man in my book.

[Guest Vince Coleman Firecracker]

Davis
Niese
Takahashi
Thole
Ummm... Gee, I suppose? Gee. I'll say Gee.

[Guest LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr]

duan wrote: I don't get the gr� for Ike Davis' season. He did OK, but as a 1b man he was distinctly average - and average is fine - but Tak was a VERY good reliever and OK starter and Niese was good starter, both of those beat being an OK 1b man in my book.

Average offensively... and great defensively. A very good reliever and "meh" fill-in starter (he was never mediocre, really-- more half-pretty-good/half-very-bad) simply ain't worth as much as Ike, even if this is ALL Ike is. There's a reason swingmen make 1-2 million a year (maybe), while the Adam LaRoches of the world make 4-8 million.

[Guest 86-Dreamer]

1. Davis
2. Niese
3. Takahashi
4. Thole
5. Carter

[Guest Edgy DC]

Votes are still coming in! Wonderful!

[bmfc1]

1. Davis
2. Niese
3. Takahashi
4. Thole
5. Tejada

[Zvon]

1. Davis
2. Takahashi
3. Niese
4. Thole
5. Tejada