Crane Pool Vote: 2009 National League Cy Young

[Guest Edgy DC]

Give me three guys: first, second, and third.

[A Boy Named Seo]

1-Lincecum
2-Wainwright
3-Carpenter

IP gives an edge to 1 & 2 over Carp.

[TransMonk]

1. Carpenter
2. Lincecum
3. Jurrjens

[ashie62]

1. Wainright
2. Carpenter
3. Lincecum

[Vic Sage]

carpenter led the other 2 in ERA, WHIP and adjERA+

Carpenter
Lincecum
Wainright

[Guest Kong76]

I'm fine with Lincecum winning.

[Guest Edgy DC]

[*:jhf729pl]Lincecum[/*:m:jhf729pl]
[*:jhf729pl]Carpenter[/*:m:jhf729pl]
[*:jhf729pl]Wainwright

And just to round 'em out (because we should have 10 votes)

[/*:m:jhf729pl]
[*:jhf729pl]Jurrjens[/*:m:jhf729pl]
[*:jhf729pl]Cain[/*:m:jhf729pl]
[*:jhf729pl]Haren[/*:m:jhf729pl]
[*:jhf729pl]Vazquez[/*:m:jhf729pl]
[*:jhf729pl]Roderiquez[/*:m:jhf729pl]
[*:jhf729pl]Jiminiez[/*:m:jhf729pl]
[*:jhf729pl]Lilly[/*:m:jhf729pl][/list:o:jhf729pl]

[Guest Edgy DC]

Cool, we have a tie point-wise.

[Guest LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr]

1. Lincecum
2. Carpenter
3. Vazquez
4. Wainwright
5. Johnson (Josh)
6. Haren
7. Jimenez
8. Pineiro
9. Kershaw
10. Rodriguez (Wandy)

[Guest John Cougar Lunchbucket]

1. Lincecum
*
2. Wainwright
3. Carpenter

hard to pick

[Guest LeiterWagnerFasterStrongr]

1. Lincecum
*
2. Wainwright
3. Carpenter

hard to pick[/quote:2y36s6xr]

I actually went back forth three times. In the end, strikeouts broke the near-tie. What did it for you?

(And I'll repeat the question wider... y'all's thought process?)

[Guest John Cougar Lunchbucket]

I took Wainwright mostly on innings pitched as a tiebreaker.

[Centerfield]

1. Jeter
2. Lincecum
3. Wainright