Guess that Met

[Cowtipper]

Unfortunately, 23 and the Midwest League are incorrect. Hint: Check the hints. (You're very close with the 23, however). The record does have to do with the league and the number of strikeouts. So I basically just answered that for you...but what was the league?

[Edgy MD]

Twenty-four strikeouts, NY-Penn League.

[Cowtipper]

Well done! It's always good to clear out a question that's been lingering for a while. A new one has been added below.



1. Who penned the "Marvelous Marv" locker sign that gave the media the idea to refer to Throneberry as Marvelous Marv?



Hint: Pitched for the Mets from 1962 to 1964.

Hint: Was 8-19 in 1962.

Hint: Pitched for the Reds from 1957 to 1961 before joining the Mets.

Hint: Was involved in this trade: "May 8, 1964: Traded by the New York Mets with a player to be named later to the Milwaukee Braves for Roy McMillan. The New York Mets sent Adrian Garrett (June 17, 1964) to the Milwaukee Braves to complete the trade."

Hint:

https://i.imgur.com/dy7e0IG.jpg>

Hint: Was 12-34 with a 5.22 ERA in his Mets career.



--originally posted by "theAmazingMet"



2. This pitcher got the save in the 1969 Mets 100th win and it was the only save he ever got as a Met. Who was that pitcher?



Hint: Pitched all of two games with the Mets.

Hint: Shares a name with an infielder who played for the Mets in 1967.

Hint: Was involved in this trade: "December 3, 1969: Traded by the New York Mets with Amos Otis to the Kansas City Royals for Joe Foy."

Hint: Also shares a name with a popular outfielder from the 1930s and '40s who some think should be in the Hall of Fame.

Hint:

https://i.imgur.com/raga0aC.png>



--originally posted by "Joe Rigatoni"



3. What Mets pitcher won on Opening Day but was only 2-15 the rest of the year? Please give me the name of the pitcher and tell me what year it happened?



--originally posted by "Joe Rigatoni"



4. In April 2010, a Met hit a home run off a former World Series winning teammate. Please give me the name of the Met and please give me the name of the pitcher he hit it off of who was a former World Series winning teammate.



--originally posted by "Joe Rigatoni"



5. The Mets were going to trade for Dickie Thon. The deal was canceled at the last minute by Owner Linda de Roulet. What was that reason?



--originally posted by "NJMetfan4life"



Running tally of correct guessers:



Johnny Lunchbucket: 62

Edgy MD: 53

stevejrogers: 40

batmagadanleadoff: 19

metsmarathon: 6

Benjamin Grimm: 4

MFS62: 3

DocTee: 2

Marshmallowmilkshake: 1

The Hot Corner: 1

[stevejrogers]

#2 is Bob Johnson



I'm guessing #5 is due to losing a Lee Mazzilli type heartthrob?

[Edgy MD]

Number 4 is most definitely tax outlaw Jerry Koosman.

[Cowtipper]

Bob Johnson is correct. As for #5, one might say it has something to do with his looks. And Koosman is correct—do you know what year that happened?

[Edgy MD]

Well, it happened in 1978, naturally, as nobody but Seaver would start on opening day before that.

[Cowtipper]

That's correct, well done. A couple new questions have been added, with hints added for the rest.



1. Who penned the "Marvelous Marv" locker sign that gave the media the idea to refer to Throneberry as Marvelous Marv?



Hint: Pitched for the Mets from 1962 to 1964.

Hint: Was 8-19 in 1962.

Hint: Pitched for the Reds from 1957 to 1961 before joining the Mets.

Hint: Was involved in this trade: "May 8, 1964: Traded by the New York Mets with a player to be named later to the Milwaukee Braves for Roy McMillan. The New York Mets sent Adrian Garrett (June 17, 1964) to the Milwaukee Braves to complete the trade."

Hint:

https://i.imgur.com/dy7e0IG.jpg>

Hint: Was 12-34 with a 5.22 ERA in his Mets career.

Hint: (from Wikipedia): "After receiving a master's degree in thermodynamics, [he] retired in 1964 at age 28 to take a job with the Chrysler Corporation. He then worked in senior management positions at Rockwell International and at Masco, and later became a professor of industrial management at Northwestern University."



--originally posted by "theAmazingMet"



2. In April 2010, a Met hit a home run off a former World Series winning teammate. Please give me the name of the Met and please give me the name of the pitcher he hit it off of who was a former World Series winning teammate.



Hint: The pitcher played for the Mets in 2011 and 2012 and the other individual, a catcher, played for them in 2010.



--originally posted by "Joe Rigatoni"



3. The Mets were going to trade for Dickie Thon. The deal was canceled at the last minute by Owner Linda de Roulet. What was that reason?



Hint: Consider the year Thon was born when this trade might have happened.



--originally posted by "NJMetfan4life"



4. What former Mets pitcher gave up Pete Rose's 4000th career hit? (Hint: He wasn't a Met at the time he gave up Rose's 4000th career hit.)



--originally posted by "Joe Rigatoni"



5. When Pete Rose had a 44 game hitting streak which broke Tommy Holmes's National League record 37 game hitting streak—what Mets pitcher did Rose get a hit off of to tie Holmes's streak of 37 and what Mets pitcher did Rose get a hit off of to break Holmes' streak at 38? Please give me the names of both Mets pitchers.



--originally posted by "Joe Rigatoni"



Running tally of correct guessers:



Johnny Lunchbucket: 62

Edgy MD: 54

stevejrogers: 41

batmagadanleadoff: 19

metsmarathon: 6

Benjamin Grimm: 4

MFS62: 3

DocTee: 2

Marshmallowmilkshake: 1

The Hot Corner: 1

[Johnny Lunchbucket]

The thermodynamic pitcher was Jay Hook

[Cowtipper]

That's correct, well done. A new question has been added and hints have been provided for the rest.



1. In April 2010, a Met hit a home run off a former World Series winning teammate. Please give me the name of the Met and please give me the name of the pitcher he hit it off of who was a former World Series winning teammate.



Hint: The pitcher played for the Mets in 2011 and 2012 and the other individual, a catcher, played for them in 2010.

Hint: The pitcher was an 18-year veteran who played for 11 major league teams. The other player was a 14-year vet who played for seven major league teams.



--originally posted by "Joe Rigatoni"



2. The Mets were going to trade for Dickie Thon. The deal was canceled at the last minute by Owner Linda de Roulet. What was that reason?



Hint: Consider the year Thon was born when this trade might have happened.

Hint: It had something to do with his age.



--originally posted by "NJMetfan4life"



3. What former Mets pitcher gave up Pete Rose's 4000th career hit? (Hint: He wasn't a Met at the time he gave up Rose's 4000th career hit.)



Hint: Won over 200 games in his major league career.



--originally posted by "Joe Rigatoni"



4. When Pete Rose had a 44 game hitting streak which broke Tommy Holmes's National League record 37 game hitting streak—what Mets pitcher did Rose get a hit off of to tie Holmes's streak of 37 and what Mets pitcher did Rose get a hit off of to break Holmes' streak at 38? Please give me the names of both Mets pitchers.



Hint: Pitcher 1: His name, one could say, was two first names. Pitcher 2: An ornithologist might be intrigued by his name.



--originally posted by "Joe Rigatoni"



5. When Jeff Francoeur and Rod Barajas hit two home runs each on Friday night to become the first pair of Mets teammates to hit two home runs in the same home game since it was done by Joe Christopher and Bob "Hawk" Taylor against the Phillies on June 20, 1964 when the Mets won 7-3. So my question is what memorable event happened at Shea Stadium the very next day (June 21, 1964)?



--originally posted by "Joe Rigatoni"



Running tally of correct guessers:



Johnny Lunchbucket: 63

Edgy MD: 54

stevejrogers: 41

batmagadanleadoff: 19

metsmarathon: 6

Benjamin Grimm: 4

MFS62: 3

DocTee: 2

Marshmallowmilkshake: 1

The Hot Corner: 1

[Johnny Lunchbucket]

3. Matlack?

[DocTee]

5. Jim Bunning's Fathers Day no hitter?

[Edgy MD]

Number four is Zat Pachry and Swaig Cran.

[Cowtipper]

It wasn't Matlack, but a good guess. It was the other Met from the era not named Seaver that accumulated a lot of wins...It was more than just a no-hitter, it was a perfect game, but Jim Bunning's performance is correct. Zachry and Swan are correct, as well. New questions have been added, with hints added for the others.



1. In April 2010, a Met hit a home run off a former World Series winning teammate. Please give me the name of the Met and please give me the name of the pitcher he hit it off of who was a former World Series winning teammate.



Hint: The pitcher played for the Mets in 2011 and 2012 and the other individual, a catcher, played for them in 2010.

Hint: The pitcher was an 18-year veteran who played for 11 major league teams. The other player was a 14-year vet who played for seven major league teams.

Hint: The pitcher was born in Santo Domingo, Dominican Republic and the other player was born in Ontario, CA.

Hint: The pitcher once threw a shutout on the final day of the regular season for the Mets. The other player started off hot for NY in his one year for the club, hitting 11 home runs with 30 RBI through May—then he fell apart.

Hint:

Pitcher—https://i.imgur.com/PM1yxsd.png> Other player—https://i.imgur.com/40InzYj.png>



--originally posted by "Joe Rigatoni"



2. The Mets were going to trade for Dickie Thon. The deal was canceled at the last minute by Owner Linda de Roulet. What was that reason?



Hint: Consider the year Thon was born when this trade might have happened.

Hint: It had something to do with his age.

Hint: His name "Dickie" is considered a diminutive.

Hint: De Roulet thought he might have been too ........ something. What was that something?

Hint:

https://i.imgur.com/zIo1B75.png>



--originally posted by "NJMetfan4life"



3. What former Mets pitcher gave up Pete Rose's 4000th career hit? (Hint: He wasn't a Met at the time he gave up Rose's 4000th career hit.)



Hint: Won over 200 games in his major league career.

Hint: Won 140 games as a Met.

Hint: Earned 0.9% of the vote on the Hall of Fame ballot in 1991.

Hint: Was an All-Star in 1968 and 1969.



--originally posted by "Joe Rigatoni"



4. What Mets pitcher has the team record for most scoreless innings in one game as a reliever?



Hint: Pitched for the Mets in 1974 and 1975.

Hint: Also played for the Royals.



--originally posted by "Joe Rigatoni"



5. What two pitchers in Mets history threw a one-hitter and the only hit they gave up was to the pitcher?



Hint: Pitcher One played for the Mets in 1966 and 1967, Pitcher Two played for them from 1971 to 1977.

Hint: Pitcher One also played for the Phillies, Tigers, Angels, Indians and White Sox. Pitcher Two also pitched for the Rangers.



--originally posted by "Joe Rigatoni"



Running tally of correct guessers:



Johnny Lunchbucket: 63

Edgy MD: 55

stevejrogers: 41

batmagadanleadoff: 19

metsmarathon: 6

Benjamin Grimm: 4

DocTee: 3

MFS62: 3

Marshmallowmilkshake: 1

The Hot Corner: 1

Edited February 25, 2024 by Guest

[Edgy MD]

Five is Tom Seaver and ... I'll say ... Pedro Martinez.

[Cowtipper]

Seaver threw plenty of one-hitters with New York and Martinez contributed, as well, however neither gave up their lone hits to an opposing pitcher. One might've been an early Met who was once traded for Nick Willhite and the other might've been an incorrect answer recently given by another member on a different question.

[DocTee]

I'll say 4 is Terry Leach.

[Cowtipper]

It wasn't Leach, but that seems like an obvious choice. The correct answer wasn't with the Mets long, but he did cram quite a bit of success into relatively few innings. In just over 22 frames one year, he had a 1.61 ERA.

[Cowtipper]

New day, new hints added above.

[Cowtipper]

New day, new hints added.

[Edgy MD]

Number 5b is clearly Jon Matlack. I'll go with Bob Shaw for 5a.

[Cowtipper]

Matlack is correct. Bob Shaw is incorrect—the correct answer might or might not have been traded by the New York Mets to the California Angels for Nick Willhite.

[Edgy MD]

Then you're teeing up Jack Hamilton for me.



I was leaning toward him, but he felt unlikely as he wasn't one to finish what he started, even in an age where that was much more common.



Also, the Mets used him more frequently out of the pen.

[Cowtipper]

Hamilton is correct, well done. A new question has been added.



1. In April 2010, a Met hit a home run off a former World Series winning teammate. Please give me the name of the Met and please give me the name of the pitcher he hit it off of who was a former World Series winning teammate.



Hint: The pitcher played for the Mets in 2011 and 2012 and the other individual, a catcher, played for them in 2010.

Hint: The pitcher was an 18-year veteran who played for 11 major league teams. The other player was a 14-year vet who played for seven major league teams.

Hint: The pitcher was born in Santo Domingo, Dominican Republic and the other player was born in Ontario, CA.

Hint: The pitcher once threw a shutout on the final day of the regular season for the Mets. The other player started off hot for NY in his one year for the club, hitting 11 home runs with 30 RBI through May—then he fell apart.

Hint:

Pitcher—https://i.imgur.com/PM1yxsd.png> Other player—https://i.imgur.com/40InzYj.png>



--originally posted by "Joe Rigatoni"



2. The Mets were going to trade for Dickie Thon. The deal was canceled at the last minute by Owner Linda de Roulet. What was that reason?



Hint: Consider the year Thon was born when this trade might have happened.

Hint: It had something to do with his age.

Hint: His name "Dickie" is considered a diminutive.

Hint: De Roulet thought he might have been too ........ something. What was that something?

Hint:

https://i.imgur.com/zIo1B75.png>



--originally posted by "NJMetfan4life"



3. What former Mets pitcher gave up Pete Rose's 4000th career hit? (Hint: He wasn't a Met at the time he gave up Rose's 4000th career hit.)



Hint: Won over 200 games in his major league career.

Hint: Won 140 games as a Met.

Hint: Earned 0.9% of the vote on the Hall of Fame ballot in 1991.

Hint: Was an All-Star in 1968 and 1969.



--originally posted by "Joe Rigatoni"



4. What Mets pitcher has the team record for most scoreless innings in one game as a reliever?



Hint: Pitched for the Mets in 1974 and 1975.

Hint: Also played for the Royals.



--originally posted by "Joe Rigatoni"



What two pitchers in Mets history threw a one-hitter and the only hit they gave up was to the pitcher?



5. A previous question was "What two pitchers in Mets history threw a one-hitter and the only hit they gave up was to the pitcher?". The answers were Jon Matlack and Jack Hamilton. Can you name the two pitchers they surrendered their hits to?



--originally posted by "Joe Rigatoni"



Running tally of correct guessers:



Johnny Lunchbucket: 63

Edgy MD: 56

stevejrogers: 41

batmagadanleadoff: 19

metsmarathon: 6

Benjamin Grimm: 4

DocTee: 3

MFS62: 3

Marshmallowmilkshake: 1

The Hot Corner: 1

[Johnny Lunchbucket]

3. Kerry Joosman

[Cowtipper]

Koosman is correct, well done. Apparently Steve Trachsel also had a one-hitter whose only hit allowed was to a pitcher (Chin hui-Tsao). That one flew under the radar.



1. In April 2010, a Met hit a home run off a former World Series winning teammate. Please give me the name of the Met and please give me the name of the pitcher he hit it off of who was a former World Series winning teammate.



Hint: The pitcher played for the Mets in 2011 and 2012 and the other individual, a catcher, played for them in 2010.

Hint: The pitcher was an 18-year veteran who played for 11 major league teams. The other player was a 14-year vet who played for seven major league teams.

Hint: The pitcher was born in Santo Domingo, Dominican Republic and the other player was born in Ontario, CA.

Hint: The pitcher once threw a shutout on the final day of the regular season for the Mets. The other player started off hot for NY in his one year for the club, hitting 11 home runs with 30 RBI through May—then he fell apart.

Hint:

Pitcher—https://i.imgur.com/PM1yxsd.png> Other player—https://i.imgur.com/40InzYj.png>



--originally posted by "Joe Rigatoni"



2. The Mets were going to trade for Dickie Thon. The deal was canceled at the last minute by Owner Linda de Roulet. What was that reason?



Hint: Consider the year Thon was born when this trade might have happened.

Hint: It had something to do with his age.

Hint: His name "Dickie" is considered a diminutive.

Hint: De Roulet thought he might have been too ........ something. What was that something?

Hint:

https://i.imgur.com/zIo1B75.png>



--originally posted by "NJMetfan4life"



3. What Mets pitcher has the team record for most scoreless innings in one game as a reliever?



Hint: Pitched for the Mets in 1974 and 1975.

Hint: Also played for the Royals.



--originally posted by "Joe Rigatoni"



What two pitchers in Mets history threw a one-hitter and the only hit they gave up was to the pitcher?



4. A previous question was "What two pitchers in Mets history threw a one-hitter and the only hit they gave up was to the pitcher?". The answers were Jon Matlack and Jack Hamilton. Can you name the two pitchers they surrendered their hits to?



--originally posted by "Joe Rigatoni"



5. Who are the only two pitchers in Mets history to strike out the side on nine pitches?



--originally posted by "Joe Rigatoni"



Running tally of correct guessers:



Johnny Lunchbucket: 64

Edgy MD: 56

stevejrogers: 41

batmagadanleadoff: 19

metsmarathon: 6

Benjamin Grimm: 4

DocTee: 3

MFS62: 3

Marshmallowmilkshake: 1

The Hot Corner: 1

[Edgy MD]

I think the current #3 refers to Jerry Cram, who pitched a bunch of innings (eight?) in that extra-inning marathon in 1974 that ended with Bake McBride scoring on a pickoff throw. Bob Murphy talked about that game all the time.



I thought his record had been broken by a nine-inning stint, but that might not have been scoreless.

[Johnny Lunchbucket]

The pitcher pictured in question 1 is Miguel Batista, but I don't really understand the question

[DocTee]

The Catcher in (1) is Rod Barajas.

[Cowtipper]

Cram, Batista and Barajas are correct. Batista and Barajas were teammates with Arizona when they beat the Yankees in 2001. Two new questions have been added.



1. The Mets were going to trade for Dickie Thon. The deal was canceled at the last minute by Owner Linda de Roulet. What was that reason?



Hint: Consider the year Thon was born when this trade might have happened.

Hint: It had something to do with his age.

Hint: His name "Dickie" is considered a diminutive.

Hint: De Roulet thought he might have been too ........ something. What was that something?

Hint:

https://i.imgur.com/zIo1B75.png>



--originally posted by "NJMetfan4life"



2. A previous question was "What two pitchers in Mets history threw a one-hitter and the only hit they gave up was to the pitcher?". The answers were Jon Matlack and Jack Hamilton. Can you name the two pitchers they surrendered their hits to?



--originally posted by "Joe Rigatoni"



3. Who are the only two pitchers in Mets history to strike out the side on nine pitches?



--originally posted by "Joe Rigatoni"



4. The Mets went 9-1 in the first 10 games in which Ike Davis appeared. In those games, Ike hit .355 with a .548 SLG, one homer, 3 doubles, 6 RBIs, and 5 runs scored. It's a pretty rare feat for a team to do put up a 9-1 record in the first ten games in which a batter (non-pitcher) appears, now having occurred only 32 times in the years 1920-1939, 1952-2010. But even more rare is when a team puts up a 10-0 record in the first ten games a batter plays with a team. It has happened a mere five times in those years. And happily -- for this thread -- one of those five times was by the New York Mets. Name the batter who helped the Mets win the first ten games in which he played. (This question is through April 2010, I'm not sure if it has happened since then).



--originally posted by "milladrive"



5. An event more rare than hitting for the cycle, one Met player ran for the cycle, getting himself thrown out at every base in one game. Who was this Met?



--originally posted by "milladrive"



Running tally of correct guessers:



Johnny Lunchbucket: 65

Edgy MD: 57

stevejrogers: 41

batmagadanleadoff: 19

metsmarathon: 6

Benjamin Grimm: 4

DocTee: 4

MFS62: 3

Marshmallowmilkshake: 1

The Hot Corner: 1