Jump to content
Grand Central Mets
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted


I've been resisting the temptation to guess Joe Smith as the #18 reliever who's been everywhere. He definitely played for the Mets and Indians. He was definitely good. But I don't see him compiling enough teenage fWAR to make this list.



But I've got a long string of bad guesses and desperation is setting in. Joe Smith, #18 reliever.


  • Replies 310
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted


Chad ochoseis wrote:

I've been resisting the temptation to guess Joe Smith as the #18 reliever who's been everywhere. He definitely played for the Mets and Indians. He was definitely good. But I don't see him compiling enough teenage fWAR to make this list.



But I've got a long string of bad guesses and desperation is setting in. Joe Smith, #18 reliever.

As difficult as it has been for the Bazooka Chewing Gum Company to accept, Smitty finished just outside of our rankings! He is the #31 fWARringest relief pitcher of the decade! Unfortunately, for you, had he been 30th (1/10th more fWAR!), you'd have five points! Instead you lose three!

gThat's an eight-point swing! I'm starting to annoy MYSELF!


#5 1B - Ryan Zimmerman

Despite being the new Bob Dylan, Ryan didn't have enough Zim to qualify at first or third! You can take that bad news and three points lost lying down, or you can GET BACK IN THE GAME!!


Damnit. Joe Smith was my next...

That's what SHE said!


Fine.



Jake Arietta. Sp12

But she didn't say THAT!



Man, Arrietta was the bee's thorax in the middle of the decade, wasn't he?! Unfortunately for you, he was just another guy (ultimately finishing 26th among starters) in the beginning and end of that decade! Fortunately for the METS, he spent the end of the decade with the Phils!! That's three points off for you, but what's good for the Mets is good for everybody!



Catchers

1) Buster Posey: Giants (MFS62)

2) Yadier Molina: Cardinals (Chad Ochoseis)

3) ____________________: __________, Athletics

4) Russell Martin: Dodgers, Yankees, Pirates, Blue Jays, Dodgers (LWFS)

5) Brian McCann: Braves, Yankees, Astros, Braves (Frayed Knot)

6) ____________________: __________, __________, __________

7) Joe Mauer: Twins

8) Miguel Montero: Diamondbacks, Cubs, Nationals (Johnny Lunchbucket)

9) ____________________: __________, __________

10) ____________________: __________, __________, __________



14) Wilson Ramos: Nationals, Rays, Phillies, Mets (Johnny Lunchbucket)



Firstbasemen

1) Joey Votto: Reds (Johnny Lunchbucket)

2) Miguel Cabrera: Tigers (metsmarathon)

3) Paul Goldschmidt: Diamondbacks, Cardinals (MFS62)

4) Freddie Freeman: Braves (LWFS)

5) ____________________: __________

6) Anthony Rizzo: Padres, Cubs

7) Edwin Encarnácion: Blue Jays, Indians (nymr83)

8) ____________________: __________

9) Adrian Gonzalez: Padres, Red Sox, Dodgers, Mets (metsmarathon)

10) Carlos Santana: Indians, Phillies, Indians (LWFS)



Secondbasemen

1) Robinson Canó: Yankees, Mariners, Mets (metsmarathon)

2) Ben Zobrist: Rays, Athletics, Royals, Cubs (nymr83)

3) José Altuve: Astros (metsmarathon)

4) Ian Kinsler: Rangers, Tigers, Angels, Red Sox, Padres

5) Dustin Pedroia: Red Sox (Johnny Lunchbucket)

6) Howie Kendrick: Angels, Dodgers, Phillies, Nationals (metsmarathon)

7) ____________________: __________, __________, __________

T8) Jason Kipnis: Indians (Chad Ochoseis)

T8) Chase Utley: Phillies, Dodgers (LWFS)

10) Daniel Murphy: Mets, Nationals (Johnny Lunchbucket)



Thirdbasemen

1) Adrian Beltre: Red Sox, Rangers (metsmarathon)

2) Josh Donaldson: Athletics, Blue Jays, Indians, Braves (MFS62)

3) Evan Longoria: Rays, Giants (metsmarathon)

4) Manny Machado: Orioles, Dodgers, Padres (metsmarathon)

5) Anthony Rendon: Nationals (LWFS)

6) Nolan Arenado: Rockies (Frayed Knot)

7) ____________________: __________

8) ____________________: __________

9) Kris Bryant: Cubs (Johnny Lunchbucket)

10) ____________________: Padres, __________, Padres

11) ____________________: Orioles, __________, __________



Shortstops

1) Troy Tulowitski: Rockies, Blue Jays, Yankees (metsmarathon)

2) Francisco Lindor: Indians (LWFS)

3) Elvis Andrus: Rangers (metsmarathon)

4) Andrelton Simmons: Braves, Angels (MFS62)

5) Xander Boegarts: Red Sox (metsmarathon)

6) Asdruba Cabrera: Indians, Nationals, Rays, Mets, Phillies, Rangers (Chad Ochoseis)

7) José Reyes: Mets, Marlins, Blue Jays, Rockies, Mets (metsmarathon)

8) Brandon Crawford: Giants (metsmarathon)

9) Jed Lowrie: Red Sox, Athletics, Astros, Athletics, Astros, Mets (LWFS)

10) Carlos Correa: Astros (metsmarathon)



Leftfielders

T1) ____________________: __________, __________

T1) Brett Gardner: Yankees (nymr83)

3) Justin Upton: Diamondbacks, Braves, Padres, Tigers, Angelsz (MFS62)

4) Ryan Braun: Brewers (metsmarathon)

5) Alex Gordon: Royals (LWFS)

6) Michael Brantley: Indians, Astros (Johnny Lunchbucket)

7) Matt Holliday: Cardinals, Yankees, Rockies (MFS62)

T8) J.D. Martinez: Astros, Tigers, Diamondbacks, Red Sox (metsmarathon)

T8) ____________________: __________

10) Carlos Conzalez: Rockies

11) Yoenis Céspedes: Athletics, Red Sox, Tigers, Mets (Steve J. Rogers)



Centerfielders

1) Mike Trout: Angels (Steve J. Rogers)

2) Andrew McCutcheon: Pirates, Giants, Yankees, Phillies (MFS62)

3) Christian Yellich: Marlins, Brewers (Chad Ochoseis)

4) Brett Gardner: Yankees (Johnny Lunchbucket)

5) Lorenzo Cain: Brewers, Royals, Brewers (LWFS)

6) ____________________: __________, __________, Dodgers, Blue Jays, __________, __________

7) ____________________: __________, __________

8) George Springer: Astros (MFS62)

9) ____________________: __________, __________

10) Starling Marte: Pirates (Chad Ochoseis)



Rightfielders

1) Giancarlo Stanton: Marlins, Yankees (Chad Ochoseis)

2) Mookie Bets: Red Sox (LWFS)

3) ____________________: Rays, __________, __________, __________

4) José Bautista: Blue Jays, Braves, Mets, Phillies (LWFS)

5) Bryce Harper: Nationals, Phillies (Steve J. Rogers)

6) Nelson Cruz: Rangers, Orioles, Mariners, Twins (metsmarathon)

7) ____________________: __________, __________, Padres, Tigers, __________

8) Jason Heyward: Braves, Cardinals, Cubs (LWFS)

9) Curtis Granderson: Yankees, Mets, Dodgers, Blue Jays, Brewers, Marlins (metsmarathon)

10) Shin-Soo Choo: Indians, Reds, Rangers (metsmarathon)



Designated Hitters

1) Nelson Crúz: Rangers, Orioles, Mariners, Twins (MFS62)

2) ____________________: __________, __________, __________, __________

2) Davíd Ortiz: Red Sox (MFS62)

4) Albert Pujols: Cardinals, Angels (metsmarathon)

5) ____________________: Brewers, __________, __________

6) Carlos Beltrán: Mets, Giants, Cardinals, Yankees, Rangers, Astros (nymr83)

7) ____________________: __________

8) ____________________: __________, __________

9) ____________________: Braves, __________

10) ____________________: Twins



Starting Pitchers

1) Clayton Kershaw: Dodgers (Chad Ochoseis)

2) Max Scherzer: Tigers, Nationals (Chad Ochoseis)

3) Justin Velrander: Tigers, Astros (Johnny Lunchbucket)

4) Chris Sale: White Sox, Red Sox (LWFS)

5) Zack Greinke: Royals, Brewers, Angels, Dodgers, Diamondbacks, Astros (Johnny Lunchbucket)

6) David Price: Rays, Tigers, Blue Jays, Red Sox (LWFS)

7) Cole Hamels: Phillies, Rangers, Cubs (LWFS)

8) Steven Strasburg: Nationals (LWFS)

9) Jon Lester: Red Sox, Athletics, Cubs (metsmarathon)

t10) Corey Kluber: Indians (LWFS)

t10) Felix Hernandez: Mariners (Johnny Lunchbucket)

12) ____________________: __________, __________, __________

13) Jacob deGrom: Mets (Steve J. Rogers)

14) Madison Bumgarner: Giants (Chad Ochoseis)

15) Gerritt Cole: Pirates, Astros (LWFS)

16) ____________________: __________, __________, __________, __________

17) ____________________: __________, Cubs

18) Adam Wainwright: Cardinals (Johnny Lunchbucket)

19) ____________________: Indians, __________

20) Rick Porcello: Tigers, Red Sox (MFS62)



Relief Pitchers

1) Aroldis Chapman: Reds, Yankees, Cubs, Yankees (Johnny Lunchbucket)

2) Kenley Jansen: Dodgers (LWFS)

3) Craig Kimbrel: Braves, Red Sox, Cubs (MFS62)

4) ____________________: Yankees, __________, __________, __________

5) ____________________: __________, __________, __________, __________

6) Dellin Betances: Yankees (metsmarathon)

7) Sean Doolittle: Athletics, Nationals (LWFS)

8) Mark Melancon: Yankees, Astros, Red Sox, Pirates, Nationals, Giants, Braves (Johnny Lunchbucket)

9) Andrew Miller: Marlins, Red Sox, Orioles, Yankees, Indians, Cardinals (Chad Ochoseis)

10) ____________________: Orioles, Rangers, __________, Cubs

11) Joakim Soria: Royals, Rangers, Tigers, Pirates, Royals, White Sox, Brewers, Athletics (LWFS)

12) ____________________: __________, __________, __________

13) Wade Davis: Rays, Royals, Cubs, Rockies (LWFS)

14) Jonathan Papelbon: Red Sox, Phillies, Nationals (Johnny Lunchbucket)

15) ____________________: __________, Astros

16) ____________________: __________, __________, Rays, Marlins, __________

17) ____________________: __________, __________, Mariners, Rays, __________

18) ____________________: __________, __________, Mets, Diamondbacks, __________, __________, White Sox, __________, Indians

19) ____________________: __________, Pirates

20) ____________________: __________, Cardinals, Nationals, Twins, Indians, Twins

21) ____________________: Twins, __________, __________, __________, Athletics

22) ____________________: __________, Yankees

23) ____________________: Royals, __________, __________

24) ____________________: __________, Nationals, __________

25) Adam Ottavino: Cardinals, Rockies, Yankees (LWFS)

26) Darren O'Day: Rangers, Mets, Orioles (Chad Ochoseis)

t27) ____________________: Indians, __________

t27) ____________________: __________, __________, Astros, __________

29) ____________________: Phillies, __________, __________, Nationals, __________

30) ____________________: Rays, __________, __________, __________, __________, Phillies, Pirates



Managers

1) Joe Maddon: Rays, Cubs (LWFS)

2) Bruce Bochy: Giants (metsmarathon)

3) Terry Francona: Red Sox, Indians (Johnny Lunchbucket)

4) ____________________: __________

5) Bob Melvin: Athletics (metsmarathon)

6) Joe Girardi: Yankees (Steve J. Rogers)

7) Mike Scioscia: Angels (Johnny Lunchbucket)

8) Bud Black: Padres, Rockies (MFS62)

9) ____________________: __________

10) ____________________: __________



12) Terry Collins: Mets (Johnny Lunchbucket)



SCORING

LWFS: 335

metsmarathon: 309

Johnny Lunchbucket: 228

MFS62: 126

Chad Ochoseis: 111

Steve J. Rogers: 63

nymr83: 50

Frayed Knot: 20



Incorrect Guesses


[TABLE][TR][/TR][TR][/TR][TR][/TR][TR][/TR][/TABLE]
[TH]Catchers[/TH][TH]Firstbasemen[/TH][TH]Secondbasemen[/TH][TH]Thirdbasemen[/TH][TH]Shortstops[/TH][TH]Leftfielders[/TH]
[TD]Yan Gomes

Salvador Perez

Carlos Ruíz

Gary Sanchez
[/TD]
[TD]José Abreu

Brandon Belt

Lucas Duda

Albert Pujols

Ryan Zimmerman
[/TD]
[TD]Justin Turner[/TD][TD]Miguel Cabrera

José Ramirez

David Wright

Ryan Zimmerman
[/TD]
[TD]Starlin Castro

Ian Desmond

Derek Jeter

Trevor Story
[/TD]
[TD]Matt Kemp[/TD]
[TH]Centerfielders[/TH][TH]Rightfielders[/TH][TH]Designated Hitters[/TH][TH]Starting Pitchers[/TH][TH]Relief Pitchers[/TH][TH]Managers[/TH]
[TD]Marcel Ozuna[/TD][TD]Jay Bruce

Nick Markakis

Ichiro Suzuki
[/TD]
[TD]J.D. Martinez

Victor Martinez

Joe Mauer
[/TD]
[TD]Jake Arrieta

Trevor Bauer

Johnny Cueto

Yu Darvish

R.A. Dickey

Sonny Gray

Kenley Jansen

C.C. Sabathia

Noah Syndergaard
[/TD]
[TD]Jeurys Familia

Tommy Kahnie

Oliver Perez

Joe Smith
[/TD]
[TD]Ron Gardenhire

A.J. Hinch

Dave Roberts

Jim/Jack Tracy
[/TD]


Posted


I'm going to go against character and not guess an Indian. The missing 2B at #7 is the always dependable Neil Walker, whose only Metly sin was to have a good year in New York while Murph had a great year in DC.


Posted


Chad ochoseis wrote:
I'm going to go against character and not guess an Indian. The missing 2B at #7 is the always dependable Neil Walker, whose only Metly sin was to have a good year in New York while Murph had a great year in DC.

There are a lot worse guesses than Walkie, who finished 11th among secondbasemen! So close, but three points leak out of your scoring bucket!



But let's be fair! Walker also committed the sin of wearing his hair like Jeff Wilpon!


#7 3B - Matt Carpenter?

What did I say about answering like a timid little baby-man?!



Carpenter is an excellent guess. He's our #8 thirdbaseman so you get 12 points, instead of the maximum 15 for a non-Met! I hope that doesn't make you cry, timid baby-Man!


Zach Britton rp22?

Another one of those fucking question marks!! Answer like you mean it or go home! You are men!



Britton is exactly right! And I will give you 15 points as much as I hate your little baby-guessing! You are within 11 of first place and it would really suck if you went into the lead like a baby!



Catchers

1) Buster Posey: Giants (MFS62)

2) Yadier Molina: Cardinals (Chad Ochoseis)

3) ____________________: __________, Athletics

4) Russell Martin: Dodgers, Yankees, Pirates, Blue Jays, Dodgers (LWFS)

5) Brian McCann: Braves, Yankees, Astros, Braves (Frayed Knot)

6) ____________________: __________, __________, __________

7) Joe Mauer: Twins

8) Miguel Montero: Diamondbacks, Cubs, Nationals (Johnny Lunchbucket)

9) ____________________: __________, __________

10) ____________________: __________, __________, __________



14) Wilson Ramos: Nationals, Rays, Phillies, Mets (Johnny Lunchbucket)



Firstbasemen

1) Joey Votto: Reds (Johnny Lunchbucket)

2) Miguel Cabrera: Tigers (metsmarathon)

3) Paul Goldschmidt: Diamondbacks, Cardinals (MFS62)

4) Freddie Freeman: Braves (LWFS)

5) ____________________: __________

6) Anthony Rizzo: Padres, Cubs

7) Edwin Encarnácion: Blue Jays, Indians (nymr83)

8) ____________________: __________

9) Adrian Gonzalez: Padres, Red Sox, Dodgers, Mets (metsmarathon)

10) Carlos Santana: Indians, Phillies, Indians (LWFS)



Secondbasemen

1) Robinson Canó: Yankees, Mariners, Mets (metsmarathon)

2) Ben Zobrist: Rays, Athletics, Royals, Cubs (nymr83)

3) José Altuve: Astros (metsmarathon)

4) Ian Kinsler: Rangers, Tigers, Angels, Red Sox, Padres

5) Dustin Pedroia: Red Sox (Johnny Lunchbucket)

6) Howie Kendrick: Angels, Dodgers, Phillies, Nationals (metsmarathon)

7) ____________________: __________, __________, __________

T8) Jason Kipnis: Indians (Chad Ochoseis)

T8) Chase Utley: Phillies, Dodgers (LWFS)

10) Daniel Murphy: Mets, Nationals (Johnny Lunchbucket)



Thirdbasemen

1) Adrian Beltre: Red Sox, Rangers (metsmarathon)

2) Josh Donaldson: Athletics, Blue Jays, Indians, Braves (MFS62)

3) Evan Longoria: Rays, Giants (metsmarathon)

4) Manny Machado: Orioles, Dodgers, Padres (metsmarathon)

5) Anthony Rendon: Nationals (LWFS)

6) Nolan Arenado: Rockies (Frayed Knot)

7) ____________________: __________

8) Matt Carpenter: Cardinals (nymr83)

9) Kris Bryant: Cubs (Johnny Lunchbucket)

10) ____________________: Padres, __________, Padres

11) ____________________: Orioles, __________, __________



Shortstops

1) Troy Tulowitski: Rockies, Blue Jays, Yankees (metsmarathon)

2) Francisco Lindor: Indians (LWFS)

3) Elvis Andrus: Rangers (metsmarathon)

4) Andrelton Simmons: Braves, Angels (MFS62)

5) Xander Boegarts: Red Sox (metsmarathon)

6) Asdruba Cabrera: Indians, Nationals, Rays, Mets, Phillies, Rangers (Chad Ochoseis)

7) José Reyes: Mets, Marlins, Blue Jays, Rockies, Mets (metsmarathon)

8) Brandon Crawford: Giants (metsmarathon)

9) Jed Lowrie: Red Sox, Athletics, Astros, Athletics, Astros, Mets (LWFS)

10) Carlos Correa: Astros (metsmarathon)



Leftfielders

T1) ____________________: __________, __________

T1) Brett Gardner: Yankees (nymr83)

3) Justin Upton: Diamondbacks, Braves, Padres, Tigers, Angelsz (MFS62)

4) Ryan Braun: Brewers (metsmarathon)

5) Alex Gordon: Royals (LWFS)

6) Michael Brantley: Indians, Astros (Johnny Lunchbucket)

7) Matt Holliday: Cardinals, Yankees, Rockies (MFS62)

T8) J.D. Martinez: Astros, Tigers, Diamondbacks, Red Sox (metsmarathon)

T8) ____________________: __________

10) Carlos Conzalez: Rockies

11) Yoenis Céspedes: Athletics, Red Sox, Tigers, Mets (Steve J. Rogers)



Centerfielders

1) Mike Trout: Angels (Steve J. Rogers)

2) Andrew McCutcheon: Pirates, Giants, Yankees, Phillies (MFS62)

3) Christian Yellich: Marlins, Brewers (Chad Ochoseis)

4) Brett Gardner: Yankees (Johnny Lunchbucket)

5) Lorenzo Cain: Brewers, Royals, Brewers (LWFS)

6) ____________________: __________, __________, Dodgers, Blue Jays, Brewers, __________

7) ____________________: __________, __________

8) George Springer: Astros (MFS62)

9) ____________________: __________, __________

10) Starling Marte: Pirates (Chad Ochoseis)



Rightfielders

1) Giancarlo Stanton: Marlins, Yankees (Chad Ochoseis)

2) Mookie Bets: Red Sox (LWFS)

3) ____________________: Rays, __________, __________, __________

4) José Bautista: Blue Jays, Braves, Mets, Phillies (LWFS)

5) Bryce Harper: Nationals, Phillies (Steve J. Rogers)

6) Nelson Cruz: Rangers, Orioles, Mariners, Twins (metsmarathon)

7) ____________________: __________, Braves, Padres, Tigers, __________

8) Jason Heyward: Braves, Cardinals, Cubs (LWFS)

9) Curtis Granderson: Yankees, Mets, Dodgers, Blue Jays, Brewers, Marlins (metsmarathon)

10) Shin-Soo Choo: Indians, Reds, Rangers (metsmarathon)



Designated Hitters

1) Nelson Crúz: Rangers, Orioles, Mariners, Twins (MFS62)

2) ____________________: __________, __________, __________, __________

2) Davíd Ortiz: Red Sox (MFS62)

4) Albert Pujols: Cardinals, Angels (metsmarathon)

5) ____________________: Brewers, __________, __________

6) Carlos Beltrán: Mets, Giants, Cardinals, Yankees, Rangers, Astros (nymr83)

7) ____________________: __________

8) ____________________: __________, __________

9) ____________________: Braves, __________

10) ____________________: Twins



Starting Pitchers

1) Clayton Kershaw: Dodgers (Chad Ochoseis)

2) Max Scherzer: Tigers, Nationals (Chad Ochoseis)

3) Justin Velrander: Tigers, Astros (Johnny Lunchbucket)

4) Chris Sale: White Sox, Red Sox (LWFS)

5) Zack Greinke: Royals, Brewers, Angels, Dodgers, Diamondbacks, Astros (Johnny Lunchbucket)

6) David Price: Rays, Tigers, Blue Jays, Red Sox (LWFS)

7) Cole Hamels: Phillies, Rangers, Cubs (LWFS)

8) Steven Strasburg: Nationals (LWFS)

9) Jon Lester: Red Sox, Athletics, Cubs (metsmarathon)

t10) Corey Kluber: Indians (LWFS)

t10) Felix Hernandez: Mariners (Johnny Lunchbucket)

12) ____________________: __________, __________, __________

13) Jacob deGrom: Mets (Steve J. Rogers)

14) Madison Bumgarner: Giants (Chad Ochoseis)

15) Gerritt Cole: Pirates, Astros (LWFS)

16) ____________________: __________, __________, __________, __________

17) ____________________: __________, Cubs

18) Adam Wainwright: Cardinals (Johnny Lunchbucket)

19) ____________________: Indians, __________

20) Rick Porcello: Tigers, Red Sox (MFS62)



Relief Pitchers

1) Aroldis Chapman: Reds, Yankees, Cubs, Yankees (Johnny Lunchbucket)

2) Kenley Jansen: Dodgers (LWFS)

3) Craig Kimbrel: Braves, Red Sox, Cubs (MFS62)

4) ____________________: Yankees, __________, __________, __________

5) ____________________: __________, __________, __________, __________

6) Dellin Betances: Yankees (metsmarathon)

7) Sean Doolittle: Athletics, Nationals (LWFS)

8) Mark Melancon: Yankees, Astros, Red Sox, Pirates, Nationals, Giants, Braves (Johnny Lunchbucket)

9) Andrew Miller: Marlins, Red Sox, Orioles, Yankees, Indians, Cardinals (Chad Ochoseis)

10) ____________________: Orioles, Rangers, __________, Cubs

11) Joakim Soria: Royals, Rangers, Tigers, Pirates, Royals, White Sox, Brewers, Athletics (LWFS)

12) ____________________: __________, __________, __________

13) Wade Davis: Rays, Royals, Cubs, Rockies (LWFS)

14) Jonathan Papelbon: Red Sox, Phillies, Nationals (Johnny Lunchbucket)

15) ____________________: __________, Astros

16) ____________________: __________, __________, Rays, Marlins, __________

17) ____________________: __________, __________, Mariners, Rays, __________

18) ____________________: __________, __________, Mets, Diamondbacks, __________, __________, White Sox, __________, Indians

19) ____________________: __________, Pirates

20) ____________________: __________, Cardinals, Nationals, Twins, Indians, Twins

21) ____________________: Twins, __________, __________, __________, Athletics

22) Zack Britton: Orioles, Yankees (metsmarathon)

23) ____________________: Royals, __________, __________

24) ____________________: __________, Nationals, __________

25) Adam Ottavino: Cardinals, Rockies, Yankees (LWFS)

26) Darren O'Day: Rangers, Mets, Orioles (Chad Ochoseis)

t27) ____________________: Indians, __________

t27) ____________________: __________, __________, Astros, __________

29) ____________________: Phillies, __________, __________, Nationals, __________

30) ____________________: Rays, __________, __________, __________, __________, Phillies, Pirates



Managers

1) Joe Maddon: Rays, Cubs (LWFS)

2) Bruce Bochy: Giants (metsmarathon)

3) Terry Francona: Red Sox, Indians (Johnny Lunchbucket)

4) ____________________: __________

5) Bob Melvin: Athletics (metsmarathon)

6) Joe Girardi: Yankees (Steve J. Rogers)

7) Mike Scioscia: Angels (Johnny Lunchbucket)

8) Bud Black: Padres, Rockies (MFS62)

9) ____________________: __________

10) ____________________: __________



12) Terry Collins: Mets (Johnny Lunchbucket)



SCORING

LWFS: 335

metsmarathon: 324

Johnny Lunchbucket: 228

MFS62: 126

Chad Ochoseis: 108

Steve J. Rogers: 63

nymr83: 62

Frayed Knot: 20



Incorrect Guesses


[TABLE][TR][/TR][TR][/TR][TR][/TR][TR][/TR][/TABLE]
[TH]Catchers[/TH][TH]Firstbasemen[/TH][TH]Secondbasemen[/TH][TH]Thirdbasemen[/TH][TH]Shortstops[/TH][TH]Leftfielders[/TH]
[TD]Yan Gomes

Salvador Perez

Carlos Ruíz

Gary Sanchez
[/TD]
[TD]José Abreu

Brandon Belt

Lucas Duda

Albert Pujols

Ryan Zimmerman
[/TD]
[TD]Justin Turner

Neil Walker
[/TD]
[TD]Miguel Cabrera

José Ramirez

David Wright

Ryan Zimmerman
[/TD]
[TD]Starlin Castro

Ian Desmond

Derek Jeter

Trevor Story
[/TD]
[TD]Matt Kemp[/TD]
[TH]Centerfielders[/TH][TH]Rightfielders[/TH][TH]Designated Hitters[/TH][TH]Starting Pitchers[/TH][TH]Relief Pitchers[/TH][TH]Managers[/TH]
[TD]Marcel Ozuna[/TD][TD]Jay Bruce

Nick Markakis

Ichiro Suzuki
[/TD]
[TD]J.D. Martinez

Victor Martinez

Joe Mauer
[/TD]
[TD]Jake Arrieta

Trevor Bauer

Johnny Cueto

Yu Darvish

R.A. Dickey

Sonny Gray

Kenley Jansen

C.C. Sabathia

Noah Syndergaard
[/TD]
[TD]Jeurys Familia

Tommy Kahnie

Oliver Perez

Joe Smith
[/TD]
[TD]Ron Gardenhire

A.J. Hinch

Dave Roberts

Jim/Jack Tracy
[/TD]


Posted


There are a lot worse guesses than Walkie, who finished 11th among secondbasemen! So close, but three points leak out of your scoring bucket!


You know who's a worse guess than Neil Walker? Brandon Phillips! I'm not even sure how long he's been in the league! But I'm going to guess him anyway as the #7 2B.


Posted


Those 2 firstbasemen are killing me. MOCKING me! who spent ten years with the same team and i cant even remember their name?? or less than 10 years but was SO GOOD they qualified anyway??


Posted


If a player was already guessed correctly at one position, would he still be an option at another position or would you have revealed him at both positions?


Old-Timey Member
Posted


=nymr83 post_id=41240 time=1595476395 user_id=54]
If a player was already guessed correctly at one position, would he still be an option at another position or would you have revealed him at both positions?

Posted


damnit, that makes too much sense. but how is he tied with gardner in left, but ahead of him in center...?!



whatever. i'm stealing your game. um... michael brantley, LF8. no other two-team outfielders fit worth a lick.


Posted


Since we are jumping on it, I'll take Buster Posey as the missing 1B #8


Posted


If a player was already guessed correctly at one position, would he still be an option at another position or would you have revealed him at both positions?


I'm curious about this one.



You know what? I'm testing that curiosity: #1 LF... Christian Yelich, REDUX!

Sokath! His eyes OPENED! Fifteen points for you plus Darmok and Jalad... ON THE OCEAN!


Chad ochoseis wrote:
There are a lot worse guesses than Walkie, who finished 11th among secondbasemen! So close, but three points leak out of your scoring bucket!


You know who's a worse guess than Neil Walker? Brandon Phillips! I'm not even sure how long he's been in the league! But I'm going to guess him anyway as the #7 2B.

I really like Brandon, even if I do confuse him with Howie Kendrick! And I'd be happy to see his name in the top ten of ... ANYTHING! Alas, here he finishes just behind Walker at #12! You lose three more points, even thought you were RIGHT (barely) about him being a worse guess than Walker! Good for you!


Those 2 firstbasemen are killing me. MOCKING me! who spent ten years with the same team and i cant even remember their name?? or less than 10 years but was SO GOOD they qualified anyway??


I actually spoke with them this morning and they actually talk with each other about you all the time!! Mocking mercilessly! Things I can't REPEAT!!


If a player was already guessed correctly at one position, would he still be an option at another position or would you have revealed him at both positions?

The judges insist this has been explained clearly and do not want to use up air time revisiting the rules at this juncture.


brandon belt 1b8

We seem to be in the Brandon Zone, here! Brandon Belt is just as good and just as wrong an answer as it was the first time somebody mentioned him! Three points off for being wrong and one more for your gross disregard of READING!


damnit, that makes too much sense. but how is he tied with gardner in left, but ahead of him in center...?!



whatever. i'm stealing your game. um... michael brantley, LF8. no other two-team outfielders fit worth a lick.

YOU SEE AND YET YOU ARE BLINDED!! Brantley is already revealed as LF#6! Two points off! Two stupid, stupid points!!


Since we are jumping on it, I'll take Buster Posey as the missing 1B #8

You have the right idea but you squint into the sun! Minus three!!


Oh, YEAH?



I'm going for #8 1B, too. WITH ANOTHER CATCHER: Joe Mauer! WINTWINS

That's what nymr really meant to write! But you actually WROTE IT!! And that's why you are DESTROYING the field!!


oh yeah, well, curtis granderson, CF6. fuck i keep forgetting about how many teams he played for after us. even when it's literally staring me in the face.

He's literally staring you in the face?! Did he become a munitions engineer after baseball?!!!



I'll tell you one thing you can be sure he HAS become! He's become FIFTEEN POINTS for YOU!!!



Catchers

1) Buster Posey: Giants (MFS62)

2) Yadier Molina: Cardinals (Chad Ochoseis)

3) ____________________: __________, Athletics

4) Russell Martin: Dodgers, Yankees, Pirates, Blue Jays, Dodgers (LWFS)

5) Brian McCann: Braves, Yankees, Astros, Braves (Frayed Knot)

6) ____________________: __________, __________, __________

7) Joe Mauer: Twins

8) Miguel Montero: Diamondbacks, Cubs, Nationals (Johnny Lunchbucket)

9) ____________________: __________, __________

10) ____________________: __________, __________, __________



14) Wilson Ramos: Nationals, Rays, Phillies, Mets (Johnny Lunchbucket)



Firstbasemen

1) Joey Votto: Reds (Johnny Lunchbucket)

2) Miguel Cabrera: Tigers (metsmarathon)

3) Paul Goldschmidt: Diamondbacks, Cardinals (MFS62)

4) Freddie Freeman: Braves (LWFS)

5) ____________________: __________

6) Anthony Rizzo: Padres, Cubs

7) Edwin Encarnácion: Blue Jays, Indians (nymr83)

8) Joe Mauer: Twins (LWFS)

9) Adrian Gonzalez: Padres, Red Sox, Dodgers, Mets (metsmarathon)

10) Carlos Santana: Indians, Phillies, Indians (LWFS)



Secondbasemen

1) Robinson Canó: Yankees, Mariners, Mets (metsmarathon)

2) Ben Zobrist: Rays, Athletics, Royals, Cubs (nymr83)

3) José Altuve: Astros (metsmarathon)

4) Ian Kinsler: Rangers, Tigers, Angels, Red Sox, Padres

5) Dustin Pedroia: Red Sox (Johnny Lunchbucket)

6) Howie Kendrick: Angels, Dodgers, Phillies, Nationals (metsmarathon)

7) ____________________: __________, __________, __________

T8) Jason Kipnis: Indians (Chad Ochoseis)

T8) Chase Utley: Phillies, Dodgers (LWFS)

10) Daniel Murphy: Mets, Nationals (Johnny Lunchbucket)



Thirdbasemen

1) Adrian Beltre: Red Sox, Rangers (metsmarathon)

2) Josh Donaldson: Athletics, Blue Jays, Indians, Braves (MFS62)

3) Evan Longoria: Rays, Giants (metsmarathon)

4) Manny Machado: Orioles, Dodgers, Padres (metsmarathon)

5) Anthony Rendon: Nationals (LWFS)

6) Nolan Arenado: Rockies (Frayed Knot)

7) ____________________: __________

8) Matt Carpenter: Cardinals (nymr83)

9) Kris Bryant: Cubs (Johnny Lunchbucket)

10) ____________________: Padres, __________, Padres

11) ____________________: Orioles, __________, __________



Shortstops

1) Troy Tulowitski: Rockies, Blue Jays, Yankees (metsmarathon)

2) Francisco Lindor: Indians (LWFS)

3) Elvis Andrus: Rangers (metsmarathon)

4) Andrelton Simmons: Braves, Angels (MFS62)

5) Xander Boegarts: Red Sox (metsmarathon)

6) Asdruba Cabrera: Indians, Nationals, Rays, Mets, Phillies, Rangers (Chad Ochoseis)

7) José Reyes: Mets, Marlins, Blue Jays, Rockies, Mets (metsmarathon)

8) Brandon Crawford: Giants (metsmarathon)

9) Jed Lowrie: Red Sox, Athletics, Astros, Athletics, Astros, Mets (LWFS)

10) Carlos Correa: Astros (metsmarathon)



Leftfielders

T1) Christian Yellich: Marlins, Brewers (LWFS)

T1) Brett Gardner: Yankees (nymr83)

3) Justin Upton: Diamondbacks, Braves, Padres, Tigers, Angelsz (MFS62)

4) Ryan Braun: Brewers (metsmarathon)

5) Alex Gordon: Royals (LWFS)

6) Michael Brantley: Indians, Astros (Johnny Lunchbucket)

7) Matt Holliday: Cardinals, Yankees, Rockies (MFS62)

T8) J.D. Martinez: Astros, Tigers, Diamondbacks, Red Sox (metsmarathon)

T8) ____________________: __________

10) Carlos Conzalez: Rockies

11) Yoenis Céspedes: Athletics, Red Sox, Tigers, Mets (Steve J. Rogers)



Centerfielders

1) Mike Trout: Angels (Steve J. Rogers)

2) Andrew McCutcheon: Pirates, Giants, Yankees, Phillies (MFS62)

3) Christian Yellich: Marlins, Brewers (Chad Ochoseis)

4) Brett Gardner: Yankees (Johnny Lunchbucket)

5) Lorenzo Cain: Brewers, Royals, Brewers (LWFS)

6) ____________________: __________, __________, Dodgers, Blue Jays, Brewers, __________

7) ____________________: __________, __________

8) George Springer: Astros (MFS62)

9) ____________________: __________, __________

10) Starling Marte: Pirates (Chad Ochoseis)



Rightfielders

1) Giancarlo Stanton: Marlins, Yankees (Chad Ochoseis)

2) Mookie Bets: Red Sox (LWFS)

3) ____________________: Rays, __________, __________, __________

4) José Bautista: Blue Jays, Braves, Mets, Phillies (LWFS)

5) Bryce Harper: Nationals, Phillies (Steve J. Rogers)

6) Nelson Cruz: Rangers, Orioles, Mariners, Twins (metsmarathon)

7) ____________________: __________, Braves, Padres, Tigers, __________

8) Jason Heyward: Braves, Cardinals, Cubs (LWFS)

9) Curtis Granderson: Yankees, Mets, Dodgers, Blue Jays, Brewers, Marlins (metsmarathon)

10) Shin-Soo Choo: Indians, Reds, Rangers (metsmarathon)



Designated Hitters

1) Nelson Crúz: Rangers, Orioles, Mariners, Twins (MFS62)

2) ____________________: __________, __________, __________, __________

2) Davíd Ortiz: Red Sox (MFS62)

4) Albert Pujols: Cardinals, Angels (metsmarathon)

5) ____________________: Brewers, __________, __________

6) Carlos Beltrán: Mets, Giants, Cardinals, Yankees, Rangers, Astros (nymr83)

7) ____________________: __________

8) ____________________: __________, __________

9) ____________________: Braves, __________

10) ____________________: Twins



Starting Pitchers

1) Clayton Kershaw: Dodgers (Chad Ochoseis)

2) Max Scherzer: Tigers, Nationals (Chad Ochoseis)

3) Justin Velrander: Tigers, Astros (Johnny Lunchbucket)

4) Chris Sale: White Sox, Red Sox (LWFS)

5) Zack Greinke: Royals, Brewers, Angels, Dodgers, Diamondbacks, Astros (Johnny Lunchbucket)

6) David Price: Rays, Tigers, Blue Jays, Red Sox (LWFS)

7) Cole Hamels: Phillies, Rangers, Cubs (LWFS)

8) Steven Strasburg: Nationals (LWFS)

9) Jon Lester: Red Sox, Athletics, Cubs (metsmarathon)

t10) Corey Kluber: Indians (LWFS)

t10) Felix Hernandez: Mariners (Johnny Lunchbucket)

12) ____________________: __________, __________, __________

13) Jacob deGrom: Mets (Steve J. Rogers)

14) Madison Bumgarner: Giants (Chad Ochoseis)

15) Gerritt Cole: Pirates, Astros (LWFS)

16) ____________________: __________, __________, __________, __________

17) ____________________: __________, Cubs

18) Adam Wainwright: Cardinals (Johnny Lunchbucket)

19) ____________________: Indians, __________

20) Rick Porcello: Tigers, Red Sox (MFS62)



Relief Pitchers

1) Aroldis Chapman: Reds, Yankees, Cubs, Yankees (Johnny Lunchbucket)

2) Kenley Jansen: Dodgers (LWFS)

3) Craig Kimbrel: Braves, Red Sox, Cubs (MFS62)

4) ____________________: Yankees, __________, __________, __________

5) ____________________: __________, __________, __________, __________

6) Dellin Betances: Yankees (metsmarathon)

7) Sean Doolittle: Athletics, Nationals (LWFS)

8) Mark Melancon: Yankees, Astros, Red Sox, Pirates, Nationals, Giants, Braves (Johnny Lunchbucket)

9) Andrew Miller: Marlins, Red Sox, Orioles, Yankees, Indians, Cardinals (Chad Ochoseis)

10) ____________________: Orioles, Rangers, __________, Cubs

11) Joakim Soria: Royals, Rangers, Tigers, Pirates, Royals, White Sox, Brewers, Athletics (LWFS)

12) ____________________: __________, __________, __________

13) Wade Davis: Rays, Royals, Cubs, Rockies (LWFS)

14) Jonathan Papelbon: Red Sox, Phillies, Nationals (Johnny Lunchbucket)

15) ____________________: __________, Astros

16) ____________________: __________, __________, Rays, Marlins, __________

17) ____________________: __________, __________, Mariners, Rays, __________

18) ____________________: __________, __________, Mets, Diamondbacks, Yankees, White Sox, White Sox, __________, Indians

19) ____________________: __________, Pirates

20) ____________________: __________, Cardinals, Nationals, Twins, Indians, Twins

21) ____________________: Twins, __________, __________, __________, Athletics

22) Zack Britton: Orioles, Yankees (metsmarathon)

23) ____________________: Royals, __________, __________

24) ____________________: __________, Nationals, __________

25) Adam Ottavino: Cardinals, Rockies, Yankees (LWFS)

26) Darren O'Day: Rangers, Mets, Orioles (Chad Ochoseis)

t27) ____________________: Indians, __________

t27) ____________________: __________, __________, Astros, Cardinals

29) ____________________: Phillies, __________, __________, Nationals, __________

30) ____________________: Rays, __________, __________, __________, __________, Phillies, Pirates



Managers

1) Joe Maddon: Rays, Cubs (LWFS)

2) Bruce Bochy: Giants (metsmarathon)

3) Terry Francona: Red Sox, Indians (Johnny Lunchbucket)

4) ____________________: __________

5) Bob Melvin: Athletics (metsmarathon)

6) Joe Girardi: Yankees (Steve J. Rogers)

7) Mike Scioscia: Angels (Johnny Lunchbucket)

8) Bud Black: Padres, Rockies (MFS62)

9) ____________________: __________

10) ____________________: __________



12) Terry Collins: Mets (Johnny Lunchbucket)



SCORING

LWFS: 365

metsmarathon: 333

Johnny Lunchbucket: 228

MFS62: 126

Chad Ochoseis: 105

Steve J. Rogers: 63

nymr83: 59

Frayed Knot: 20



Incorrect Guesses


[TABLE][TR][/TR][TR][/TR][TR][/TR][TR][/TR][/TABLE]
[TH]Catchers[/TH][TH]Firstbasemen[/TH][TH]Secondbasemen[/TH][TH]Thirdbasemen[/TH][TH]Shortstops[/TH][TH]Leftfielders[/TH]
[TD]Yan Gomes

Salvador Perez

Carlos Ruíz

Gary Sanchez
[/TD]
[TD]José Abreu

Brandon Belt

Lucas Duda

Buster Posey

Albert Pujols

Ryan Zimmerman
[/TD]
[TD]Justin Turner

Brandon Phillips

Neil Walker
[/TD]
[TD]Miguel Cabrera

José Ramirez

David Wright

Ryan Zimmerman
[/TD]
[TD]Starlin Castro

Ian Desmond

Derek Jeter

Trevor Story
[/TD]
[TD]Matt Kemp[/TD]
[TH]Centerfielders[/TH][TH]Rightfielders[/TH][TH]Designated Hitters[/TH][TH]Starting Pitchers[/TH][TH]Relief Pitchers[/TH][TH]Managers[/TH]
[TD]Marcel Ozuna[/TD][TD]Jay Bruce

Nick Markakis

Ichiro Suzuki
[/TD]
[TD]J.D. Martinez

Victor Martinez

Joe Mauer
[/TD]
[TD]Jake Arrieta

Trevor Bauer

Johnny Cueto

Yu Darvish

R.A. Dickey

Sonny Gray

Kenley Jansen

C.C. Sabathia

Noah Syndergaard
[/TD]
[TD]Jeurys Familia

Tommy Kahnie

Oliver Perez

Joe Smith
[/TD]
[TD]Ron Gardenhire

A.J. Hinch

Dave Roberts

Jim/Jack Tracy
[/TD]


Posted


Edgy MD wrote:

=metsmarathon post_id=41243 time=1595478175 user_id=83]
whatever. i'm stealing your game. um... michael brantley, LF8. no other two-team outfielders fit worth a lick.

YOU SEE AND YET YOU ARE BLINDED!! Brantley is already revealed as LF#6! Two points off! Two stupid, stupid points!!


Posted


#18 RP Tyler Clip-joint?

That's a 20-pointer that's been hanging off the rim for, like EVER! It's about time somebody put it DOWN!



Edgy MD wrote:


whatever. i'm stealing your game. um... michael brantley, LF8. no other two-team outfielders fit worth a lick.

YOU SEE AND YET YOU ARE BLINDED!! Brantley is already revealed as LF#6! Two points off! Two stupid, stupid points!!


oh, fuck me. i was looking at the list he was on, not the one he was missing from. michael brantley, CF7

Yes and NO! He's CF9!! Still, you get nine points, and that'll help put some gas in your boat!



Catchers

1) Buster Posey: Giants (MFS62)

2) Yadier Molina: Cardinals (Chad Ochoseis)

3) ____________________: __________, Athletics

4) Russell Martin: Dodgers, Yankees, Pirates, Blue Jays, Dodgers (LWFS)

5) Brian McCann: Braves, Yankees, Astros, Braves (Frayed Knot)

6) ____________________: __________, __________, __________

7) Joe Mauer: Twins

8) Miguel Montero: Diamondbacks, Cubs, Nationals (Johnny Lunchbucket)

9) ____________________: __________, __________

10) ____________________: __________, __________, __________



14) Wilson Ramos: Nationals, Rays, Phillies, Mets (Johnny Lunchbucket)



Firstbasemen

1) Joey Votto: Reds (Johnny Lunchbucket)

2) Miguel Cabrera: Tigers (metsmarathon)

3) Paul Goldschmidt: Diamondbacks, Cardinals (MFS62)

4) Freddie Freeman: Braves (LWFS)

5) ____________________: __________

6) Anthony Rizzo: Padres, Cubs

7) Edwin Encarnácion: Blue Jays, Indians (nymr83)

8) Joe Mauer: Twins (LWFS)

9) Adrian Gonzalez: Padres, Red Sox, Dodgers, Mets (metsmarathon)

10) Carlos Santana: Indians, Phillies, Indians (LWFS)



Secondbasemen

1) Robinson Canó: Yankees, Mariners, Mets (metsmarathon)

2) Ben Zobrist: Rays, Athletics, Royals, Cubs (nymr83)

3) José Altuve: Astros (metsmarathon)

4) Ian Kinsler: Rangers, Tigers, Angels, Red Sox, Padres

5) Dustin Pedroia: Red Sox (Johnny Lunchbucket)

6) Howie Kendrick: Angels, Dodgers, Phillies, Nationals (metsmarathon)

7) ____________________: __________, __________, __________

T8) Jason Kipnis: Indians (Chad Ochoseis)

T8) Chase Utley: Phillies, Dodgers (LWFS)

10) Daniel Murphy: Mets, Nationals (Johnny Lunchbucket)



Thirdbasemen

1) Adrian Beltre: Red Sox, Rangers (metsmarathon)

2) Josh Donaldson: Athletics, Blue Jays, Indians, Braves (MFS62)

3) Evan Longoria: Rays, Giants (metsmarathon)

4) Manny Machado: Orioles, Dodgers, Padres (metsmarathon)

5) Anthony Rendon: Nationals (LWFS)

6) Nolan Arenado: Rockies (Frayed Knot)

7) ____________________: __________

8) Matt Carpenter: Cardinals (nymr83)

9) Kris Bryant: Cubs (Johnny Lunchbucket)

10) ____________________: Padres, __________, Padres

11) ____________________: Orioles, __________, __________



Shortstops

1) Troy Tulowitski: Rockies, Blue Jays, Yankees (metsmarathon)

2) Francisco Lindor: Indians (LWFS)

3) Elvis Andrus: Rangers (metsmarathon)

4) Andrelton Simmons: Braves, Angels (MFS62)

5) Xander Boegarts: Red Sox (metsmarathon)

6) Asdruba Cabrera: Indians, Nationals, Rays, Mets, Phillies, Rangers (Chad Ochoseis)

7) José Reyes: Mets, Marlins, Blue Jays, Rockies, Mets (metsmarathon)

8) Brandon Crawford: Giants (metsmarathon)

9) Jed Lowrie: Red Sox, Athletics, Astros, Athletics, Astros, Mets (LWFS)

10) Carlos Correa: Astros (metsmarathon)



Leftfielders

T1) Christian Yellich: Marlins, Brewers (LWFS)

T1) Brett Gardner: Yankees (nymr83)

3) Justin Upton: Diamondbacks, Braves, Padres, Tigers, Angelsz (MFS62)

4) Ryan Braun: Brewers (metsmarathon)

5) Alex Gordon: Royals (LWFS)

6) Michael Brantley: Indians, Astros (Johnny Lunchbucket)

7) Matt Holliday: Cardinals, Yankees, Rockies (MFS62)

T8) J.D. Martinez: Astros, Tigers, Diamondbacks, Red Sox (metsmarathon)

T8) ____________________: __________

10) Carlos Conzalez: Rockies

11) Yoenis Céspedes: Athletics, Red Sox, Tigers, Mets (Steve J. Rogers)



Centerfielders

1) Mike Trout: Angels (Steve J. Rogers)

2) Andrew McCutcheon: Pirates, Giants, Yankees, Phillies (MFS62)

3) Christian Yellich: Marlins, Brewers (Chad Ochoseis)

4) Brett Gardner: Yankees (Johnny Lunchbucket)

5) Lorenzo Cain: Brewers, Royals, Brewers (LWFS)

6) ____________________: __________, __________, Dodgers, Blue Jays, Brewers, __________

7) ____________________: __________, __________

8) George Springer: Astros (MFS62)

9) Michael Brantley: Indians, Astros (metsmarathon)

10) Starling Marte: Pirates (Chad Ochoseis)



Rightfielders

1) Giancarlo Stanton: Marlins, Yankees (Chad Ochoseis)

2) Mookie Bets: Red Sox (LWFS)

3) ____________________: Rays, __________, __________, __________

4) José Bautista: Blue Jays, Braves, Mets, Phillies (LWFS)

5) Bryce Harper: Nationals, Phillies (Steve J. Rogers)

6) Nelson Cruz: Rangers, Orioles, Mariners, Twins (metsmarathon)

7) ____________________: __________, Braves, Padres, Tigers, __________

8) Jason Heyward: Braves, Cardinals, Cubs (LWFS)

9) Curtis Granderson: Yankees, Mets, Dodgers, Blue Jays, Brewers, Marlins (metsmarathon)

10) Shin-Soo Choo: Indians, Reds, Rangers (metsmarathon)



Designated Hitters

1) Nelson Crúz: Rangers, Orioles, Mariners, Twins (MFS62)

2) ____________________: __________, __________, __________, __________

2) Davíd Ortiz: Red Sox (MFS62)

4) Albert Pujols: Cardinals, Angels (metsmarathon)

5) ____________________: Brewers, __________, __________

6) Carlos Beltrán: Mets, Giants, Cardinals, Yankees, Rangers, Astros (nymr83)

7) ____________________: __________

8) ____________________: __________, __________

9) ____________________: Braves, __________

10) ____________________: Twins



Starting Pitchers

1) Clayton Kershaw: Dodgers (Chad Ochoseis)

2) Max Scherzer: Tigers, Nationals (Chad Ochoseis)

3) Justin Velrander: Tigers, Astros (Johnny Lunchbucket)

4) Chris Sale: White Sox, Red Sox (LWFS)

5) Zack Greinke: Royals, Brewers, Angels, Dodgers, Diamondbacks, Astros (Johnny Lunchbucket)

6) David Price: Rays, Tigers, Blue Jays, Red Sox (LWFS)

7) Cole Hamels: Phillies, Rangers, Cubs (LWFS)

8) Steven Strasburg: Nationals (LWFS)

9) Jon Lester: Red Sox, Athletics, Cubs (metsmarathon)

t10) Corey Kluber: Indians (LWFS)

t10) Felix Hernandez: Mariners (Johnny Lunchbucket)

12) ____________________: __________, __________, __________

13) Jacob deGrom: Mets (Steve J. Rogers)

14) Madison Bumgarner: Giants (Chad Ochoseis)

15) Gerritt Cole: Pirates, Astros (LWFS)

16) ____________________: __________, __________, __________, __________

17) ____________________: __________, Cubs

18) Adam Wainwright: Cardinals (Johnny Lunchbucket)

19) ____________________: Indians, __________

20) Rick Porcello: Tigers, Red Sox (MFS62)



Relief Pitchers

1) Aroldis Chapman: Reds, Yankees, Cubs, Yankees (Johnny Lunchbucket)

2) Kenley Jansen: Dodgers (LWFS)

3) Craig Kimbrel: Braves, Red Sox, Cubs (MFS62)

4) ____________________: Yankees, __________, __________, __________

5) ____________________: __________, __________, __________, __________

6) Dellin Betances: Yankees (metsmarathon)

7) Sean Doolittle: Athletics, Nationals (LWFS)

8) Mark Melancon: Yankees, Astros, Red Sox, Pirates, Nationals, Giants, Braves (Johnny Lunchbucket)

9) Andrew Miller: Marlins, Red Sox, Orioles, Yankees, Indians, Cardinals (Chad Ochoseis)

10) ____________________: Orioles, Rangers, __________, Cubs

11) Joakim Soria: Royals, Rangers, Tigers, Pirates, Royals, White Sox, Brewers, Athletics (LWFS)

12) ____________________: __________, Astros, __________

13) Wade Davis: Rays, Royals, Cubs, Rockies (LWFS)

14) Jonathan Papelbon: Red Sox, Phillies, Nationals (Johnny Lunchbucket)

15) ____________________: __________, Astros

16) ____________________: __________, __________, Rays, Marlins, __________

17) ____________________: Marlins, __________, Mariners, Rays, __________

18) Tyler Clippard: Nationals, Athletics, Mets, Diamondbacks, Yankees, White Sox, Astros, Blue Jays, Indians (LWFS

19) ____________________: __________, Pirates

20) ____________________: __________, Cardinals, Nationals, Twins, Indians, Twins

21) ____________________: Twins, __________, __________, __________, Athletics

22) Zack Britton: Orioles, Yankees (metsmarathon)

23) ____________________: Royals, __________, __________

24) ____________________: __________, Nationals, __________

25) Adam Ottavino: Cardinals, Rockies, Yankees (LWFS)

26) Darren O'Day: Rangers, Mets, Orioles (Chad Ochoseis)

t27) ____________________: Indians, __________

t27) ____________________: __________, __________, Astros, Cardinals

29) ____________________: Phillies, __________, __________, Nationals, __________

30) ____________________: Rays, __________, __________, __________, __________, Phillies, Pirates



Managers

1) Joe Maddon: Rays, Cubs (LWFS)

2) Bruce Bochy: Giants (metsmarathon)

3) Terry Francona: Red Sox, Indians (Johnny Lunchbucket)

4) ____________________: __________

5) Bob Melvin: Athletics (metsmarathon)

6) Joe Girardi: Yankees (Steve J. Rogers)

7) Mike Scioscia: Angels (Johnny Lunchbucket)

8) Bud Black: Padres, Rockies (MFS62)

9) ____________________: __________

10) ____________________: __________



12) Terry Collins: Mets (Johnny Lunchbucket)



SCORING

LWFS: 385

metsmarathon: 342

Johnny Lunchbucket: 228

MFS62: 126

Chad Ochoseis: 105

Steve J. Rogers: 63

nymr83: 59

Frayed Knot: 20



Incorrect Guesses


[TABLE][TR][/TR][TR][/TR][TR][/TR][TR][/TR][/TABLE]
[TH]Catchers[/TH][TH]Firstbasemen[/TH][TH]Secondbasemen[/TH][TH]Thirdbasemen[/TH][TH]Shortstops[/TH][TH]Leftfielders[/TH]
[TD]Yan Gomes

Salvador Perez

Carlos Ruíz

Gary Sanchez
[/TD]
[TD]José Abreu

Brandon Belt

Lucas Duda

Buster Posey

Albert Pujols

Ryan Zimmerman
[/TD]
[TD]Justin Turner

Brandon Phillips

Neil Walker
[/TD]
[TD]Miguel Cabrera

José Ramirez

David Wright

Ryan Zimmerman
[/TD]
[TD]Starlin Castro

Ian Desmond

Derek Jeter

Trevor Story
[/TD]
[TD]Matt Kemp[/TD]
[TH]Centerfielders[/TH][TH]Rightfielders[/TH][TH]Designated Hitters[/TH][TH]Starting Pitchers[/TH][TH]Relief Pitchers[/TH][TH]Managers[/TH]
[TD]Marcel Ozuna[/TD][TD]Jay Bruce

Nick Markakis

Ichiro Suzuki
[/TD]
[TD]J.D. Martinez

Victor Martinez

Joe Mauer
[/TD]
[TD]Jake Arrieta

Trevor Bauer

Johnny Cueto

Yu Darvish

R.A. Dickey

Sonny Gray

Kenley Jansen

C.C. Sabathia

Noah Syndergaard
[/TD]
[TD]Jeurys Familia

Tommy Kahnie

Oliver Perez

Joe Smith
[/TD]
[TD]Ron Gardenhire

A.J. Hinch

Dave Roberts

Jim/Jack Tracy
[/TD]


Posted


#10 C Matt "Not Wieners" Wieters

Wieters peters down to #12, but here's the thing!! Even though he is not on the board, since you only missed by two spots, I'll subtract only two points!



See?! Reasonable!


3b 7. Commissioner Alex Gordon

Please don't bother trying to find him — he's not there! Let me tell you 'bout the way you just lost three points!


#9 C JT Realmuto

Seeing how JT got into only 11 games in the first half of the decade, that guess was J.T. RealCRAPPY, costing you a trio of points!


Dj lemahieu 2b7.

Can you guys suddenly only answer with guys with initials for a first name?! D.J. is all the way down at #15! OK, that's not that far down!!



Catchers

1) Buster Posey: Giants (MFS62)

2) Yadier Molina: Cardinals (Chad Ochoseis)

3) ____________________: __________, Athletics

4) Russell Martin: Dodgers, Yankees, Pirates, Blue Jays, Dodgers (LWFS)

5) Brian McCann: Braves, Yankees, Astros, Braves (Frayed Knot)

6) ____________________: __________, __________, __________

7) Joe Mauer: Twins

8) Miguel Montero: Diamondbacks, Cubs, Nationals (Johnny Lunchbucket)

9) ____________________: __________, __________

10) ____________________: __________, __________, __________



14) Wilson Ramos: Nationals, Rays, Phillies, Mets (Johnny Lunchbucket)



Firstbasemen

1) Joey Votto: Reds (Johnny Lunchbucket)

2) Miguel Cabrera: Tigers (metsmarathon)

3) Paul Goldschmidt: Diamondbacks, Cardinals (MFS62)

4) Freddie Freeman: Braves (LWFS)

5) ____________________: __________

6) Anthony Rizzo: Padres, Cubs

7) Edwin Encarnácion: Blue Jays, Indians (nymr83)

8) Joe Mauer: Twins (LWFS)

9) Adrian Gonzalez: Padres, Red Sox, Dodgers, Mets (metsmarathon)

10) Carlos Santana: Indians, Phillies, Indians (LWFS)



Secondbasemen

1) Robinson Canó: Yankees, Mariners, Mets (metsmarathon)

2) Ben Zobrist: Rays, Athletics, Royals, Cubs (nymr83)

3) José Altuve: Astros (metsmarathon)

4) Ian Kinsler: Rangers, Tigers, Angels, Red Sox, Padres

5) Dustin Pedroia: Red Sox (Johnny Lunchbucket)

6) Howie Kendrick: Angels, Dodgers, Phillies, Nationals (metsmarathon)

7) ____________________: __________, __________, __________

T8) Jason Kipnis: Indians (Chad Ochoseis)

T8) Chase Utley: Phillies, Dodgers (LWFS)

10) Daniel Murphy: Mets, Nationals (Johnny Lunchbucket)



Thirdbasemen

1) Adrian Beltre: Red Sox, Rangers (metsmarathon)

2) Josh Donaldson: Athletics, Blue Jays, Indians, Braves (MFS62)

3) Evan Longoria: Rays, Giants (metsmarathon)

4) Manny Machado: Orioles, Dodgers, Padres (metsmarathon)

5) Anthony Rendon: Nationals (LWFS)

6) Nolan Arenado: Rockies (Frayed Knot)

7) ____________________: __________

8) Matt Carpenter: Cardinals (nymr83)

9) Kris Bryant: Cubs (Johnny Lunchbucket)

10) ____________________: Padres, __________, Padres

11) ____________________: Orioles, __________, __________



Shortstops

1) Troy Tulowitski: Rockies, Blue Jays, Yankees (metsmarathon)

2) Francisco Lindor: Indians (LWFS)

3) Elvis Andrus: Rangers (metsmarathon)

4) Andrelton Simmons: Braves, Angels (MFS62)

5) Xander Boegarts: Red Sox (metsmarathon)

6) Asdruba Cabrera: Indians, Nationals, Rays, Mets, Phillies, Rangers (Chad Ochoseis)

7) José Reyes: Mets, Marlins, Blue Jays, Rockies, Mets (metsmarathon)

8) Brandon Crawford: Giants (metsmarathon)

9) Jed Lowrie: Red Sox, Athletics, Astros, Athletics, Astros, Mets (LWFS)

10) Carlos Correa: Astros (metsmarathon)



Leftfielders

T1) Christian Yellich: Marlins, Brewers (LWFS)

T1) Brett Gardner: Yankees (nymr83)

3) Justin Upton: Diamondbacks, Braves, Padres, Tigers, Angelsz (MFS62)

4) Ryan Braun: Brewers (metsmarathon)

5) Alex Gordon: Royals (LWFS)

6) Michael Brantley: Indians, Astros (Johnny Lunchbucket)

7) Matt Holliday: Cardinals, Yankees, Rockies (MFS62)

T8) J.D. Martinez: Astros, Tigers, Diamondbacks, Red Sox (metsmarathon)

T8) ____________________: __________

10) Carlos Conzalez: Rockies

11) Yoenis Céspedes: Athletics, Red Sox, Tigers, Mets (Steve J. Rogers)



Centerfielders

1) Mike Trout: Angels (Steve J. Rogers)

2) Andrew McCutcheon: Pirates, Giants, Yankees, Phillies (MFS62)

3) Christian Yellich: Marlins, Brewers (Chad Ochoseis)

4) Brett Gardner: Yankees (Johnny Lunchbucket)

5) Lorenzo Cain: Brewers, Royals, Brewers (LWFS)

6) ____________________: __________, __________, Dodgers, Blue Jays, Brewers, __________

7) ____________________: __________, __________

8) George Springer: Astros (MFS62)

9) Michael Brantley: Indians, Astros (metsmarathon)

10) Starling Marte: Pirates (Chad Ochoseis)



Rightfielders

1) Giancarlo Stanton: Marlins, Yankees (Chad Ochoseis)

2) Mookie Bets: Red Sox (LWFS)

3) ____________________: Rays, __________, __________, __________

4) José Bautista: Blue Jays, Braves, Mets, Phillies (LWFS)

5) Bryce Harper: Nationals, Phillies (Steve J. Rogers)

6) Nelson Cruz: Rangers, Orioles, Mariners, Twins (metsmarathon)

7) ____________________: __________, Braves, Padres, Tigers, __________

8) Jason Heyward: Braves, Cardinals, Cubs (LWFS)

9) Curtis Granderson: Yankees, Mets, Dodgers, Blue Jays, Brewers, Marlins (metsmarathon)

10) Shin-Soo Choo: Indians, Reds, Rangers (metsmarathon)



Designated Hitters

1) Nelson Crúz: Rangers, Orioles, Mariners, Twins (MFS62)

2) ____________________: __________, __________, __________, __________

2) Davíd Ortiz: Red Sox (MFS62)

4) Albert Pujols: Cardinals, Angels (metsmarathon)

5) ____________________: Brewers, __________, __________

6) Carlos Beltrán: Mets, Giants, Cardinals, Yankees, Rangers, Astros (nymr83)

7) ____________________: __________

8) ____________________: __________, __________

9) ____________________: Braves, __________

10) ____________________: Twins



Starting Pitchers

1) Clayton Kershaw: Dodgers (Chad Ochoseis)

2) Max Scherzer: Tigers, Nationals (Chad Ochoseis)

3) Justin Velrander: Tigers, Astros (Johnny Lunchbucket)

4) Chris Sale: White Sox, Red Sox (LWFS)

5) Zack Greinke: Royals, Brewers, Angels, Dodgers, Diamondbacks, Astros (Johnny Lunchbucket)

6) David Price: Rays, Tigers, Blue Jays, Red Sox (LWFS)

7) Cole Hamels: Phillies, Rangers, Cubs (LWFS)

8) Steven Strasburg: Nationals (LWFS)

9) Jon Lester: Red Sox, Athletics, Cubs (metsmarathon)

t10) Corey Kluber: Indians (LWFS)

t10) Felix Hernandez: Mariners (Johnny Lunchbucket)

12) ____________________: __________, __________, __________

13) Jacob deGrom: Mets (Steve J. Rogers)

14) Madison Bumgarner: Giants (Chad Ochoseis)

15) Gerritt Cole: Pirates, Astros (LWFS)

16) ____________________: __________, __________, __________, __________

17) ____________________: __________, Cubs

18) Adam Wainwright: Cardinals (Johnny Lunchbucket)

19) ____________________: Indians, __________

20) Rick Porcello: Tigers, Red Sox (MFS62)



Relief Pitchers

1) Aroldis Chapman: Reds, Yankees, Cubs, Yankees (Johnny Lunchbucket)

2) Kenley Jansen: Dodgers (LWFS)

3) Craig Kimbrel: Braves, Red Sox, Cubs (MFS62)

4) ____________________: Yankees, __________, __________, __________

5) ____________________: __________, __________, __________, __________

6) Dellin Betances: Yankees (metsmarathon)

7) Sean Doolittle: Athletics, Nationals (LWFS)

8) Mark Melancon: Yankees, Astros, Red Sox, Pirates, Nationals, Giants, Braves (Johnny Lunchbucket)

9) Andrew Miller: Marlins, Red Sox, Orioles, Yankees, Indians, Cardinals (Chad Ochoseis)

10) ____________________: Orioles, Rangers, __________, Cubs

11) Joakim Soria: Royals, Rangers, Tigers, Pirates, Royals, White Sox, Brewers, Athletics (LWFS)

12) ____________________: __________, Astros, __________

13) Wade Davis: Rays, Royals, Cubs, Rockies (LWFS)

14) Jonathan Papelbon: Red Sox, Phillies, Nationals (Johnny Lunchbucket)

15) ____________________: __________, Astros

16) ____________________: __________, __________, Rays, Marlins, __________

17) ____________________: Marlins, __________, Mariners, Rays, __________

18) Tyler Clippard: Nationals, Athletics, Mets, Diamondbacks, Yankees, White Sox, Astros, Blue Jays, Indians (LWFS

19) ____________________: __________, Pirates

20) ____________________: __________, Cardinals, Nationals, Twins, Indians, Twins

21) ____________________: Twins, __________, __________, __________, Athletics

22) Zack Britton: Orioles, Yankees (metsmarathon)

23) ____________________: Royals, __________, __________

24) ____________________: __________, Nationals, __________

25) Adam Ottavino: Cardinals, Rockies, Yankees (LWFS)

26) Darren O'Day: Rangers, Mets, Orioles (Chad Ochoseis)

t27) ____________________: Indians, __________

t27) ____________________: __________, __________, Astros, Cardinals

29) ____________________: Phillies, __________, __________, Nationals, __________

30) ____________________: Rays, __________, __________, __________, __________, Phillies, Pirates



Managers

1) Joe Maddon: Rays, Cubs (LWFS)

2) Bruce Bochy: Giants (metsmarathon)

3) Terry Francona: Red Sox, Indians (Johnny Lunchbucket)

4) ____________________: __________

5) Bob Melvin: Athletics (metsmarathon)

6) Joe Girardi: Yankees (Steve J. Rogers)

7) Mike Scioscia: Angels (Johnny Lunchbucket)

8) Bud Black: Padres, Rockies (MFS62)

9) ____________________: __________

10) ____________________: __________



12) Terry Collins: Mets (Johnny Lunchbucket)



SCORING

LWFS: 380

metsmarathon: 336

Johnny Lunchbucket: 228

MFS62: 126

Chad Ochoseis: 105

Steve J. Rogers: 63

nymr83: 59

Frayed Knot: 20



Incorrect Guesses


[TABLE][TR][/TR][TR][/TR][TR][/TR][TR][/TR][/TABLE]
[TH]Catchers[/TH][TH]Firstbasemen[/TH][TH]Secondbasemen[/TH][TH]Thirdbasemen[/TH][TH]Shortstops[/TH][TH]Leftfielders[/TH]
[TD]Yan Gomes

Salvador Perez

JT Realmuto

Carlos Ruíz

Gary Sanchez

Matt Wieters
[/TD]
[TD]José Abreu

Brandon Belt

Lucas Duda

Buster Posey

Albert Pujols

Ryan Zimmerman
[/TD]
[TD]Justin Turner

Brandon Phillips

Neil Walker
[/TD]
[TD]Miguel Cabrera

Alex Gordon

José Ramirez

David Wright

Ryan Zimmerman
[/TD]
[TD]Starlin Castro

Ian Desmond

Derek Jeter

Trevor Story
[/TD]
[TD]Matt Kemp[/TD]
[TH]Centerfielders[/TH][TH]Rightfielders[/TH][TH]Designated Hitters[/TH][TH]Starting Pitchers[/TH][TH]Relief Pitchers[/TH][TH]Managers[/TH]
[TD]Marcel Ozuna[/TD][TD]Jay Bruce

Nick Markakis

Ichiro Suzuki
[/TD]
[TD]J.D. Martinez

Victor Martinez

Joe Mauer
[/TD]
[TD]Jake Arrieta

Trevor Bauer

Johnny Cueto

Yu Darvish

R.A. Dickey

Sonny Gray

Kenley Jansen

C.C. Sabathia

Noah Syndergaard
[/TD]
[TD]Jeurys Familia

Tommy Kahnie

Oliver Perez

Joe Smith
[/TD]
[TD]Ron Gardenhire

A.J. Hinch

Dave Roberts

Jim/Jack Tracy
[/TD]


Posted


6) ____________________: __________, __________, Dodgers, Blue Jays, Brewers, __________


Curtis Granderson!


Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
The Grand Central Mets Caretaker Fund
The Grand Central Mets Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Mets community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...