Edgy DC wrote: Not for nothing, but it seems that traits like an "ever-present smile and infectious exuberance" (from Kirby Puckett's Hall of Fame plaque) are the sort that are treated as much more noteable for a black player --- Kirby Puckett, Mookie Wilson, Ernie Banks, maybe Roy Campanella. Roger McDowell's goofiness and giddiness made him notable, but he wasn't widely called "a great ambassador for the game" (although all those appearances at the MTV Softball Classic suggest he maybe was). Gary Carter's affability got him widely labelled a "phony." I only mention it because (a) the white folks who largely run baseball and largely support baseball perhaps more need black players who are sweet and fun and happy rather than surly and threatening and ( maybe it's a tough row to hoe --- to project joy and enthusasm on days when maybe you're not feeling it, and run the risk of being labelled a Tom in private conversation among your fellow black players. Perhaps because it is the minority that faces so much adversity that he/she is given a tacit approval to be surly that when we become familiar with a person of color who seems to be able to shed the weight of that burden and just 'be happy' no matter what the circumstance, that person stands out. So on the flip side of Roger McDowell and Gary Carter you have guys like Eddie Murray or Albert Belle who, while 'surly' were never compared in terms of personality to a guy like Ty Cobb. Why? Because it is more 'acceptable' for the black player to be surly? And just to further muddy the argument, Bill 'Spaceman' Lee, Yogi Berra and Turk Wendall are three white guys who are labled as goofy, affable, happy-go-lucky. ="Yancy Street Gang"]The question posed was, more or less, who would you be more afraid of encountering in a dark alley, Kevin Mitchell or Lastings Milledge? Mitchell's earned his scary rep, but the comparison to Milledge can only be racism. Maybe the Mets can hire Mookie as a smiling coach to teach Lastings to be non-threatening. I agree this is ludicrous as Mitchell was a gang member but let's not forget that our friend Lastings did have some sexual assualt charges levied against him. Girlfriend or no, his actions were illiegal enough for teams to take pause before drafting a 'can't-miss' prospect.