Not funny at all, I only quoted the part of your post that I was addressing at that particular point. If you'll comprehend what you're reading, you'll see that I also dealt with the other part of your post by saying this: All of Hernandez's attributes (what you refer to as hitting in the minors, defense, and comfortable pitchers) are not worth keeping a .185 hitter in a starting role in the majors either. If you think hitting in the minors, defense, and comfortable pitchers is worth keeping his bat in the lineup, then I guess he is your ideal starting second baseman. It's actually not worth it. If you'll notice, I said Andy's bat will decide if he should keep starting or not. It's all on him, not on some imagined love-affair with Kaz. Let him show he can hit. How hard is this? Am I really not giving the guy a fair shake because I'm asking him to hit at a major league level? __________________ I'd still like to know where you thought I said "benched all-star that got into his manager's doghouse". EDIT: grammar