batmagadanleadoff wrote: John Cougar Lunchbucket wrote: I gotta be honest here. What Utley did last year was shifty but pretty much what ballplayers have been doing for 150 years. Tejada got hurt because Muffy gave him a terrible throw and Tejada made a poor decision to turn his back on an oncoming runner, especially a known scumbag like Utley. This is exactly, exactly what I've been saying since like 10 minutes after the play happened. Only with a heck of a lot of resistance to follow. Preach on. I also agree with you about Synd's actions. In hindsight, especially with hindsight, it was a stupid, stupid thing to do. What the hell did he think he would accomplish by throwing the ball six feet behind Utley where the pitch was likelier to strike someone in the Mets dugout instead of Utley? Even without the ejections, all that pitch does is to let the Dodgers know that the incident is now over without them having to fear any meaningful retaliation. If I was Noah and looked into trying to come up with a way to throw at Utley, I would have arrived at the same conclusion. Actually, I may have thought "chin music" and that kind of brush back is 10 times more dangerous than what he actually did. So he figured the best chance he had of giving Utley a message (& not get tossed) was to just let him hear one go by. Don't have to be close at 99. He'll hear that whistle blow. And it would instill fear in, yes, even in my mighty personal nemesis, Chase Ugley. < spl chek knows