batmagadanleadoff wrote: Ordonez had one outstanding defensive season, 1999, where he might've even been deserving of the Gold Glove he won, and one more excellent season defensively - 1997. Beyond those two, he was nothing special, despite his knack for consistently making visually breathtaking and highlight-worthy plays. In fact, there's plenty of evidence that his backups, Vizcaino, Lopez et. al. were at least just as efficient defensively as Ordonez, though not nearly as pretty to look at. Other than 1999, he was never in the conversation of best fielding shortstop, either in the Majors, or in the NL. well, cite said evidence maybe? Because they didn't talk him up on Sportscenter? Please, Gold Gloves are an offense award, and if the 1999 infield offense wasn't so outrageously ridiculous he wouldn't have won it then either. You're talking about an award Derek Jeter won in 2010 despite hanging out near the bottom of most fielding statistic categories except errors which is laughable because only one shortstop made fewer plays on balls in the zone that season than him.