Centerfield wrote: ... His last three starts were all 5 innings, and the ER were 0, 2, and 3 respectively. If that's his upside, with his downside being blowups like last night, then this guy just is not a big league quality pitcher. But that's consistent with his career performance. He's a mid-4 ERA pitcher with a 6ip/gs average. if he gives us 5ip/2.5runs per game, that's a 5th starter, and that's him. It's the games where he gets blown out that are the problem. That it happened in COL is not a shock. But after he started the season with 3 awful starts, 4 of his next 5 starts are pretty much what we should have expected: 5 ip / 0,0,2,3 runs scored. So i'd say he was, in fact, rolling in a good direction [for him] before last night. He should just never be asked to start at high altitude, cuz his shit don't play there. I'm not arguing that he's a good pitcher, or that it was good we signed him. He's not and it wasn't. But if you cut him some slack for a slow start due to ST injury, then he's given us what we should have expected. I'd prefer more consistency [6ip/3r per game would be fine]. But even DeGrom isn't winning with this lineup, so i don't know that this season has been about Vargas' failures. Even with him in the rotation, we've got a good one. It's that the 2 big bats we brought in for big money have been injured and/or unproductive, and our young prospects haven't been exactly precocious in their development.