Martinez and Baines do not get in, ever. Their careers were extended due to the bastardization of baseball known as the DH.... that is absolute and total bullshit, at least as far as Martinez is concerned. He was one of the most deadly hitters of his generation. If there were no DH, they'd have plunked him at 1b. You can't take away points because they played in the AL. Obviously, they get no BOOST from defensive contributions, but i don't get the logic of diminishing their accomplishments because of the rules they played under and how they were used by their managers. If you have an issue with the DH, write to the commissioner. Don't penalize HOF-caliber players. Certainly there are already 1-dimensional players in the HOF (ozzie, reggie, etc), so it is only a matter of whether your 1 dimension is of a signifcant magnitude to warrant HOF consideration. To automatically reject a player from consideration because he was primarily a DH is unfair, agenda-based, and frankly lazy.