Two terrific players, and I salute both of their causes and welcome both openly to Cooperstown, but ... is this, like, one of the least legendary classes there has been? I know it's probably not the least, because some years, the BBWAA produced only one inductee, and then the Hall kind of put the screws to the Vets Committee to make sure they selected somebody to round out the ceremony, but that second guy would have been typically weaker. With his glovework, Rolen's probably in the top 100 players of all time, and The Crime Dog is probably in the top 250. Neither will bring shame on the Hall, but ... I'd still take Lou Whitaker or Bobby Grich over either. I'd certainly take Keith Hernandez or even Jack Clark over McGriff. McGriff also seemingly switched teams every three years, so I guess part of the tarnish is that there's no huge natural constituency for him.