His defense is neither a best-case nor a worst-case scenario, which I think we all could live with if he's doing his job with the bat. On that score, is rate stats are close to normal with the glaring exception of his slugging being down 100 points. It sometimes happens that while someone is forced to make an adjustment in one part of their game, they fail to make adjustments in others. Sucks, but considering that we're on our fourth shortstop, it's something we have to grind along with. And that's really what's to love about Murphy, I think. Total grinder. Like he stays with a groundball he mishandles, and sometimes makes the play anyhow, he stays with his career vicissitudes through a lot of bumps and fumbles too. I think he may yet make something out of this season. But he could lose some time to Valdy and Q-Tip if and when Tejada and Cede�o come back.