Vic Sage wrote: I think they are treated as better by some voters and commentators (and fans) just because they are more easily understood. Albom owns that one with pride. Today, every stat matters. There is no end to the appetite for categories -- from OBP to OPS to WAR. I mean, OMG! The number of triples hit while wearing a certain-colored underwear is probably being measured as we speak. So in areas such as "how many Cabrera home runs would have gone out in Angel Stadium of Anaheim" or "batting average when leading off an inning" or "Win Probability Added," Trout had the edge. At least this is what we were told. I mean, did you do the math? I didn't. I like to actually see the sun once in a while. But Trout excelled in the kind of numbers that weren't even considered a few years ago, mostly because A) They were impossible to measure, and Nobody gave a hoot. This is what drives me batty about the whole thing. Many of his superior numbers --- on-base percentage, stolen bases, and stolen base percentage --- are neither remotely new nor remotely esoteric. Albom is also unashamed about the "I cover Detroit sports and if you actually saw the guy, you'd know" argument. Besides, if you live in Detroit, you didn't need a slide rule. This was an easy choice. People here watched Cabrera, 29, tower above the game in 2012. Day after day, game after game, he was a Herculean force. Valuable? What other word was there? How many late-inning heroics? How many clutch hits? And he only missed one game all year. Yeah, well other people live in Southern California and saw a lot more of Trout than you did. That's why we ask people to attempt to be objective. Numbers are good for that. And be careful with those last three sentences in that paragraph. You're asking for statistical answers. OMG! The funny thing is that he plays the "And his team won so you know he's better!" argument even when it doesn't hold up. How about the fact that Cabrera's team made the playoffs and Trout's did not? ("Yes," countered Team Trout, "but the Angels actually won more games.") How about the fact that Cabrera played the whole season while Trout started his in the minors? ("Yes," said the Trout Shouters, "but the Angels won a greater percentage with Trout than Detroit did with Cabrera.") Hey, thanks for smashing your own arguments, Mitch. How about just dropping that stupid paragraph to begin with? How did Fire Joe Morgan! get shut down? There had to have been money to be made in stopping this sort of thing.