SteveJRogers wrote: Edgy MD wrote: It's odd. You think "Who was the greatest manager of my lifetime?" and many of the names that come up --- Weaver, Whitey Herzog, Davey Johnson, Bobby Cox --- were guys that won one and only one championship. Do you want to give Earl an "honorary" title for 1983? No. My point was largely about how (1) the World Series winner doesn't necessarily give you the best team, and (2) great managing doesn't necessarily result in successful teams. Earl's best years came in the midst of the rise three of baseball's great teams --- the Swinging A's, the Red Machine, and the Battlin' Bombers, plus some damn good Dodger and Red Sox and Phillie teams, but I'd take Weaver over Williams, Anderson, and Martin (and Zimmer and LaSorda, and Green), probably without even thinking too long on the issue. (I'd think long and hard about Herzog, though.)