Let's start by saying that John McGraw at his best would have had a hard time keeping his head above water with the hand Torre was dealt in Queens. Good: Loyally and faithfully stuck with the vestiges of Gil Hodges' old coaching staff. Even rehired them when he took over in Atlanta. After Willie Mays was banned from holding an MLB job, he hired his old batterymate Bob Gibson, because he believed in the power of a legend on the bench. As with Jeter years later, he tried to develop Mazzilli into a captain in training. It didn't work, but there's a long history of good managers identifying a young player and infusing him with all the manager's philosophy, making him the embodiment of the manager and his expectations on the field and in the clubhouse, allowing the manager to stay out of folks' hair. Stengel did it with Berra. Hodges/Seaver. Valentine/Alfonzo. Was a willing and able face of a franchise, if a listing one. Bad: Consistently chose defense over offense up the middle, leaving the team with gaping holes in the lineup. Gaping. And I'm a Doug Flynn fan. Had too much faith in Alex Trevi�o's bat. Liked Trevi�o so much, in fact, that during a team slump, he tried to inject the lineup with offense by putting Alex behind the dish for a few days and moving Stearns to third. Probably unrelated, but Stearns hurt his elbow and was never the same. Allowed Gibson's assessment of Roger Clemens to be passed up the chain, leading the team to lowball him, and him to go to college. Was an early adopter of the designated-closer mentality, pitching Allen in late innings with a lead, and pitching Reardon when behind. Among other things, it probably led to the team selling Reardon below value.