In fairness to Kurkjian, he was arguing that it's close between JdG and Scherzer but he gives the edge to Scherzer because the ERA is close AND Scherzer leads in strikeouts AND in WAR AND is innings pitched AND in batting average against as well as in wins. It's not like little Timmy is some kind of stuck in the mud old timer wondering why he ever sold his horse for a car. Wilbon is simply obstinate on this topic. Working as he does on an opinion show, he's set himself up as the anti-stats/anti-'millennials' standard bearer where he takes it far beyond just this particular topic. Neither he nor Kornheiser could understand it when Felix Hernandez won the AL CY with a 13-12 record while David Price was 19-6 and Sabathia was 21-7 (so it's not like the writers haven't done this before) and neither could either understand why Trout should be MVP (he wasn't) the year Miggy Cabrera won the Triple Crown and no amount of explaining how while, yes, Cabrera had a slightly better offensive year, Trout was vastly superior in fielding, running, throwing, positional value, etc., could get them off that argument. Don't care what McCarthy thinks/says but, c'mon folks, he's saying it about his own guy. Let's not pretend some of us (or Gary or Keith or Ronnie) wouldn't be making the same points if the roles were reversed (see Dickey vs Kershaw).