Girardi's 'tightness' (pressure?, intensity?) is probably more a long term problem than a short one, something that wears a team/media down over time. And he did last 10 years in the Bronx following his one year stint for a goofy owner in Miami where he got canned after winning Manager of the Year (for whatever that's worth). Showalter is a different kind of guy from Girardi but carries a similar type of rep where his voice starts to wear thin after a while as guys get tired of hearing him, but it's not like he was getting bounced early either: four, three, four, and nine seasons at each of his stops. But those same traits can also be a short term boost to a club, and if Brodie and the brass think they have a win-now club ...