Howard's problem, despite a heckuva prime, is that he both got started late -- half season at age 25, 1st full season (and MVP) at 26 -- and then petered out early -- essentially was a sub-par player after age 31. From 2006 thru '11 he was .274/.370/.559 // 939 (139 OPS+) with an MVP, four Top-5 MVPs, and a WS title. He's one of those first half career HoF'ers whose second half failed to maintain: Mattingly, Dale Murphy, Andruw Jones, and hell, maybe David Wright too. Speaking of 1st basemen - who do you like? A, B, or C YrsPABAOBASLGHRRBIOPS+T-10 MVP 148,029.268.360.5094091,2981262, no wins 178,553.296.384.4361621,0711283, one win 136,531.258.343.5153821,1941254, one win Player A is Mark Teixeira, a one and done last night at a shockingly low (to me anyway) 1.5%. C is R. Howard, also a one and done. B is Keef Keith, of course, was a fielder at that position like no other, but Teixeira was real damn good. Howard = not good at all.