It was more like Benigno got his job at FAN by winning a contest, and it all started with the infamous 'Eli from Westchester'. Eli was an ex-college football player (somewhere in the midwest) and also black which by itself seemed unusual among most FAN listeners/callers in those days. The theme in his calls was always the same, that all the NYC sports teams were racist and he rode that theme into becoming what I guess could be called the station's first 'celebrity' caller. Some hosts eventually banned him from their shows because they knew they'd get the same take over and over again often without supporting evidence (not always right but never in doubt). Others embraced him knowing that a call from him essentially programmed the rest of their show as the next several hours would be filled with other callers pushing back at Eli's rant du jour. Fast forward a couple years to right around this time of year when regular hosts' vacations and broken schedules left the station with a few hours here and there to fill and so they announced that Eli would be given the opportunity to fill in one or two of those short shifts. This quickly caused a backlash with callers wondering why being an overt racist got you increased time on air rather than less. FAN then took a quick back step by 'clarifying' that, ummm, what we really meant was that we were going to give these mini time-slots to several of our better known callers .. yeah, that was our plan all along. One of those callers was 'Joe from Saddle River', a restaurant seafood salesman who'd call often, mostly about the Jets. Turned out that, given the chance to solo, Eli turned into a very tame version of his usual self (perhaps under orders) and the consensus was that he pretty much bombed while the one who supposedly came off the best among the half-dozen or so fill-ins was Benigno. By this point Steve Somers was itching to leave the overnight slot where he had toiled for years for some normal working hours so Benigno, who I believe had a small bit of radio experience in his younger days, was offered the overnight shift if he took some courses to re-up his skills.