OK, when I say that Bartolo was necessary it didn't mean specifically that HE was necessary, only that somebody was and he was one of a short list of somebodies - the Bartolo Bunch if you will despite the fact that this winter's group admittedly aren't as outwardly similar as the 'Benson Bunch' of years gone by (even considering Bronson Arroyo's hair of gold) But this was the crew (chime in if I've missed any) who were available via FA-gency last winter, so chances are if the Mets didn't sign Bartolo they were going to have to sign someone. So far things have worked out fairly well with the one we did sign, starting with the fact that Colon has made all of his starts--something Niese & Gee haven't been able to do, Mejia was pulled from doing, Matsuzaka hasn't done that well, and Montero, Syndergaard, or deGrom weren't ready to do. And by looking at the other contracts, I don't quite get the "going cheap" comments; only Tanaka was substantially more expensive and I think we all knew the Wilpons weren't going there (and maybe that's a good thing based on this week's developments) and it's tough to complain about Bartolo representing the cheap route and being overpaid at the same time. So here's the Bartolo Bunch with contract outlines and Y-t-D starts, ERA & WHiP (bold numbers show where the numbers are superior to Colon's 3.99 ERA, 1.18 WHIP) PITCHERAGEYRs$$/YrTEAMGSERAWHIPUBALDO JIMINEZ30412.50BALT184.521.54HIROKI KURODA29116.00YANX194.101.21HIRO TANAKA25722.14YANX182.511.01ERVIN SANTANA31114.00ATL174.011.26TIM HUDSON38211.50SFG182.871.10JOSH JOHNSON2918.00TOR0�-�-DAN HAREN33110.00LAD194.231.27RICKY NOLASCO31412.25MINN185.901.62PHIL HUGHES2838.00MINN193.921.21SCOTT KAZMIR30211.00OAK192.380.98SCOTT FELDMAN31310.00HOU164.331.37MIKE PELFREY3025.50MINN57.991.99MATT GARZA30412.50MILW193.691.18BRONSON ARROYO37211.75ARZ144.081.29AJ BURNETT37211.25PHIL203.831.33 So the ones clearly better so far are -- Tanaka - although the elbow injury throws all that into question; Hudson - although not much younger and coming off a broken ankle was at least as big a risk; Kazmir - virtually the same deal by the team that let Colon go, he's certainly younger and fitter although arguably less durable and one of the rumored reasons Oakland was so keen on the Samardzija deal was due to questions about Kazmir's durability; or about the same -- Hughes - so far anyway, and yet still the counter will be made about how he wouldn't have been able to do this in New York Garza - for twice the length .. plus, do you want to look at that facial hair for the next four years?!? Burnett - ummm. whatever Meanwhile Josh Johnson never got out of ST and will miss the entire season, Pelfrey's been a disaster, Arroyo just went down to TJ surgery, Jimenez has been markedly worse, Santana would have cost a draft pick on top of the money, and none of those signings look as bad right now as Ricky Nolasco's.