I thought that Lincecum deserved his 2008 Cy, fair and square, even though Johan was jobbed out of several wins by his bullpen. But Johan was the NL's second best pitcher that year, which was not reflected in the CYA balloting. Here's a question: Johan's been in the majors long enough to be eligible for HOF consideration. If yesterday was his last game ever, does he deserve to get in, or does he need to do more? OE: I'd say that Johan's peak is HOF worthy. CY in 2004 and 2006. Rookd out of the CY in 2005. ERA champ and 2d best NL pitcher in 2008. But the voters might want more accumulation on the counting stats.