Still scoreless through 4 Going to the NYTimes Archives and a Leonard Koppett article on the BBWAA Baseball Centennial Award event 7/20/1969: Ruth and John McGraw voted greatest player & mgr DiMaggio and Stengel got the living versions Gehrig, Hornsby, Pie Traynor, Wagner in the infield Cobb joins Ruth and DiMaggio in the outfield Mickey Cochrane behind the plate Big Train and Lefty Grove as your top pitchers George Sisler and Musial tied for 1B for the living category Gehringer and Cronin at 2nd and SS, and Traynor was living at the time. DiMaggio was joined by Ted Williams and Willie Mays (only active player) in the outfield, Bill Dickey behind the plate, and Bob Feller along with a still living Grove. Musial, Mays and Feller are the only ones still living nearly 40 years later now. Mays was actually the only active player in the running for the greatest team lineup according to this article!