I never got the love for Fonzie Re: "the love" -- Fonzie being the best 2B the Mets ever had (and one of the better 3B they ever had pre-Ventura and -Wright ) coincided with the Mets' ascension from mediocrities to contenders. I don't think it was a coincidence that once Alfonzo became an everyday player, the Mets improved steadily. Throw in that he was a dream in that "does all the little things" way, shuttled between positions as asked and went out in style (buying up ad space atop the caps to thank his fans after signing with San Fran once Phillips didn't bother trying to keep him) -- plus he was thoughtful enough to not come back to haunt us by being better after he left than he was when he was here -- and you have a Met whose halo is pretty sturdy. My particular treasured memory: In June 1997, the Mets were playing the Pirates on Fox, having just recently proven themselves a capable ballclub (over .500, in the Wild Card hunt, days after Mlicki beat the MFYs) and McCarver, still part of the family, was telling Joe Buck that we may be looking at the best all-around third baseman in the National League right now. Buck was snottily dismissive until Fonzie hit the go-ahead homer in the bottom of the eighth, at which point he was all "ah, I see what you mean" to Tim. Aside from the home run and winning that game, just that sense of a Met sneaking up on people and showing we had somebody underrated for a change...stuff like that, that's where the love comes from. Then again, Fonzie's not alone in Left Off The Ballot company from that Met era. On the 2009 ballot (the one that included Rickey Henderson) there was no mention of first-time eligibles Todd Hundley or Rick Reed, each a two-time Met All-Star, the former a franchise power-hitting record-holder, the other a mainstay on two postseason clubs who pitched well in each postseason. Mike Bordick left off the same ballot, but screw him.