Edgy MD wrote: Chapman is dead on. Heck, the award should be called The Kelvin Chapman Award. Edgy MD wrote: With respect to Bob Ojeda, Dark Horse 1986 has to be Ray Knight. He was a complete load in 1985, and in 1986, he was earning MVP votes. Or am I shortchanging Rick Anderson here? Anderson is closer to the dark horse ideal, perhaps, but probably not a big enough contributor to the 1986 trajectory. They were already pretty close to death grip mode when Uncle Andy showed up and his most famous appearance came in a losing cause. When he returned, the division was safely tucked away. Ojeda had a career year, and certainly rose above his projected maybe-fifth starter status, but given where he was coming out of ‘85, Knight might be premier candidate.