Joe Posnanski's criteria: There are 50 non-Hall of Famers — fifty of them, and again, I'm not even including active players or players who have not yet come up on the ballot — who have more Wins Above Average than any of the bottom 100 Hall of Famers. Many people will talk about, say, this year's ballot entry Mark Buehrle as a very good pitcher but not quite a Hall of Famer. That may be so. But he is one of the 50 I'm talking about. If Buehrle was elected to the Hall of Fame, he would immediately have a viable argument of being better than 100 players already in the Hall of Fame. We just don't realize how many incredible players are not in the Hall of Fame … or at least, I didn't realize it. So I decided to count down the 100 greatest players who are outside the Hall. I'm going to explain the countdown here, but first let me define terms: I am only including players on this list who could be elected into the Hall of Fame tomorrow. In my original list, I included all players, including active players and those who are waiting to get on the Hall of Fame ballot. I'll rank a few of those below to get us warmed up. And the ranking is not based solely on the player's greatness. No, I am ranking them in the order that I would vote them into the Hall of Fame. As you probably know, the Baseball Writers are asked to consider every player based on five characteristics: Playing ability Integrity Sportsmanship Character Contribution to team(s) on which they played. There has been a lot of controversy about the Hall of Fame character clause. The bottom four categories — integrity, sportsmanship, character, team contributions — have mostly been used to disqualify or attempt to disqualify players. But I don't think that was ever the entire point. I think the point was for Hall of Fame voters to be open-minded about greatness, to consider players who not only were great on the field but also were a credit to baseball, players who made the game better, players who brought color and life and teamwork and leadership to the sport. I have tried to think about all that in these rankings. But, of course, the most important quality by far is “playing ability.” I try not to forget that. https://theathletic.com/2202108/2020/11/27/the-outsiders-hall-of-fame-top-100/?source=user_shared_articlehttps://theathletic.com/2202108/2020/11/27/the-outsiders-hall-of-fame-top-100/?source=user_shared_article